Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

who began buddhism: scientists reveal the history

10 min read0 Ansichten

At a glance

Excavations at Lumbini pushed the earliest Buddhist shrine to the sixth century BC. What the evidence settles about Buddhism's origins, and what it doesn't.

white Buddha statue on body of water
Photo by Mattia Faloretti on Unsplash

A friend wrote to me last month with a question she had been carrying since a trip to Nepal. Standing in the Sacred Garden at Lumbini, she had read a sign, then a guidebook, then three contradictory websites, and came away with the impression that scientists had recently settled the question of who began Buddhism and when. Was it true, she wanted to know, that the whole thing had been dated?

I have some sympathy for the confusion. For years I repeated the tidy version myself: a prince, a tree, a date around 500 BC, case closed. The research is more interesting than that, and narrower. What archaeology has now dated is a building. The man it points to is real. Getting from one to the other means reading the evidence honestly, including where it stops.

The trench beneath the Maya Devi Temple

Between 2011 and 2013 an international team excavated inside the Maya Devi Temple at Lumbini, the UNESCO World Heritage site in southern Nepal that tradition identifies as the Buddha's birthplace. Robin Coningham of Durham University co-led the work with Kosh Prasad Acharya of the Pashupati Area Development Trust, under a UNESCO project funded by the Japanese government. The digging happened over three winters, when the water table falls low enough to work. Monks, nuns and pilgrims kept visiting throughout, and the archaeologists went barefoot or in slippers because shoes are not permitted in the shrine.

Beneath the brick temple built in the third century BC under the patronage of the emperor Ashoka, the team found postholes left by a timber railing. The posts themselves had long since rotted. Around an open central space with no roof, clay floors were worn smooth by foot traffic, and mineralised tree roots ran through the void. Later brick temples repeated the timber layout almost exactly, century after century, which is what continuity of worship looks like in section.

For dating, the team used two methods on different materials: radiocarbon analysis of charcoal fragments from the postholes, and optically stimulated luminescence on grains of sand, a technique that establishes when sediment was last exposed to daylight. The charcoal produced a range of roughly 800 to 545 BC. The shrine is described as dating to about 550 BC, and the peer-reviewed results appeared in the journal Antiquity in December 2013.

"What we have got is the earliest Buddhist shrine in the world," Coningham said at the time. He also argued that the story of Lumbini as a pilgrimage site created under Ashokan patronage "must be modified", because the place had already been embellished for centuries before Ashoka's builders arrived.

What a shrine can and cannot tell you

A building dates a practice, not a person. The Lumbini sequence establishes that people were treating this patch of ground as sacred in the sixth century BC, generations before the earliest Buddhist structures previously known anywhere. It does not record a birth, and no archaeologist claims otherwise. Whether the tree at the centre of the timber railing is the tree of the nativity story cannot be tested.

One detail from the excavation is suggestive. The site showed none of the debris that usually accompanies early Indian tree shrines, such as sacrificial offerings or cut animal bone. "It was very clean, in fact, which points to the Buddhist tradition of nonviolence and nonofferings," Coningham told National Geographic. That is an argument from absence, and he treated it as such.

Other specialists pushed back hard. Richard Gombrich, a historian of Buddhism at Oxford, told reporters the claim was "rubbish" and that there was no evidence the structure had been a Buddhist shrine at all. Ruth Young of the University of Leicester noted dryly that "archaeologists love claiming that they have found the earliest or the oldest of something". Julia Shaw of University College London pointed out that tree worship was ubiquitous in ancient Indian religions, so the Lumbini shrine could be an older ritual site unconnected to the historical Buddha. Lars Fogelin of the University of Arizona took the opposite view, calling Buddhist affiliation the most plausible reading given how tree shrines appear in friezes at other early Buddhist sites.

The UNESCO project record for the excavations adds a detail the headlines mostly missed: a few hundred metres south of the temple, researchers found remains of a village dating back to 1300 BC, pushing settlement in the area back by roughly a thousand years. Coningham's own summary of the dispute was the most durable line to come out of the press conference. "There will always be questions," he said. "And there always should be questions."

Profile view of a stone Buddha statue illuminated by warm light against black

Photo by Jan Kopřiva on Unsplash

Four centuries of argument about a birthday

The reason a single trench caused such a stir is that the Buddha's dates had been contested for well over a century, with no physical evidence to arbitrate. Nepali authorities have long favoured 623 BC. A widely recognised scholarly range places his life at 563 to 483 BC. Others have argued for 448 to 368 BC, and some historians treated 390 to 340 BC as the realistic window. Every tradition agrees he died at 80; none of them wrote anything down while he was alive.

The earliest fixed point is Ashoka's sandstone pillar at Lumbini, which still stands and records the emperor's visit to the birthplace of the sage of the Shakyas. That inscription, from the third century BC, gave scholars a terminus. Everything before it depended on oral tradition transmitted across centuries, and different Buddhist communities in Asia preserved different chronologies.

What the sixth-century date offers, beyond a number, is context. Coningham has described the Buddha's lifetime as a period of enormous social and economic upheaval, with cities, kings and coinage appearing across the Gangetic plain and a merchant class growing outside Brahmin ranks. A teaching that told people they did not need priestly lineage to be reborn, and that possessions were not the point, had an obvious audience. The New Scientist report on the excavation makes the same connection between the shrine and the world that produced it.

A teacher in the Gangetic plain, and a word coined in Europe

Siddhartha Gautama, a member of the Shakya clan in what is now the Nepal-India border region, is the figure the tradition describes. He left a privileged life, sought teachers, sat under a fig tree at Bodh Gaya until he found what he was looking for, preached a first sermon at Sarnath, and died at Kusinagara. Those four places remain the faith's principal pilgrimage sites.

Here is the second answer to the question of who began Buddhism, and it tends to surprise people. The word itself is European. It appears in French writing as early as 1817, in Michel-Jean-François Ozeray's study of "Buddou", and in English with Edward Upham's History and Doctrine of Buddhism in 1829. The spelling only settled in the 1860s. Eugène Burnouf's magisterial Introduction à l'histoire du buddhisme indien of 1844 gave European readers their first detailed account drawn from a critical comparison of sources. The term does not exist in Asian languages as a native category, and scholars of the period have described it as an invention of orientalist philology, assembled from manuscripts in the libraries of Paris and London.

So the practice began around a teacher in the northern Indian subcontinent in the middle of the first millennium BC, while "Buddhism" as a named, world-spanning religion was catalogued in Europe in the 1820s and 1840s. Both facts are true, and they explain why the phrase "who began Buddhism" is harder to answer than it looks.

The manuscripts are the other half of the scientific story. The British Library Kharosthi fragments, acquired in 1994, are 29 birch-bark scrolls in the Gandhari language and Kharosthi script, buried in a clay pot and dated to roughly the first century AD. They are the oldest surviving substantial collection of Buddhist manuscripts, and they still postdate the Buddha by several hundred years. A single Gandhara scroll held at the Library of Congress was radiocarbon dated to between the first century BC and the first century AD.

The city where he grew up

Roughly 27 kilometres west of Lumbini lies Tilaurakot, the fortified site most archaeologists identify as ancient Kapilavastu, capital of the Shakya kingdom and the place where the prince spent his early life. Excavations there have found a planned walled city with cardinal road grids, fortifications that began as timber palisades in the sixth century BC and were later rebuilt in clay and then brick, and occupation layers reaching back to the eighth century BC.

In February 2026, Nepal's Department of Archaeology, the Lumbini Development Trust and Durham University's UNESCO Chair announced a find they consider a step change: the first apsidal Buddhist temple identified in Nepal. Apsidal temples have a curved rear wall and an entrance platform opposite, and the earliest known examples were cut into rock. This one, dated to somewhere between the third and fifth centuries AD, sits inside a monastery courtyard built over the ruins of the earlier palace complex. The central walled compound there measures 100 by 100 metres, enclosed by a brick wall 1.5 metres thick. The temple was built to enshrine an earlier stupa, and the volume of oil lamps recovered suggests sustained pilgrimage.

Kosh Prasad Acharya noted that the remains were first recorded in the late nineteenth century by the Indian archaeologist P.C. Mukherjee, who called it a "Deva Temple". The Rising Nepal report on the announcement quotes Coningham describing the discovery as vital for understanding the history and heritage of Buddhism in South Asia. Its shape closely resembles the apsidal temple at Sarnath, where the Buddha is said to have given his first sermon.

black and grey Buddha statue on top of hill

Photo by Jamie Street on Unsplash

The politics of a World Heritage listing

In July 2025, at the 47th session of the World Heritage Committee in Paris, Nepal's nomination for Tilaurakot-Kapilavastu was deferred on the advice of ICOMOS, the advisory body that assesses cultural nominations. The committee asked Nepal to complete the investigation of the apsidal temple with more precise dating, to research the site's religious architecture further, and to consider resubmitting the property as a boundary modification of the existing Lumbini listing rather than a standalone site. ICOMOS also observed that whether Tilaurakot is Kapilavastu remains contested.

That contest is regional as much as scholarly. India promotes Piprahwa and Ganwaria in Uttar Pradesh as the ancient Shakya capital, and Nepali heritage officials have pointed to that disagreement as one reason the bid struggled. "Perhaps we should have pursued a joint trans-boundary nomination with India," Gopi Krishna Sharma of the Lumbini Development Trust told the Kathmandu Post. Sanuraja Shakya, the trust's member secretary, was blunter, describing weak heritage diplomacy. Nepal has said it intends to resubmit.

The stakes are not only symbolic. Lumbini draws around a million pilgrims and visitors a year, and Coningham estimated years ago that annual pilgrim traffic into South Asia would reach 22 million within five years. Tilaurakot, for all its archaeological weight, receives a fraction of that. Conservation budgets in the region depend on the visibility that inscription brings.

What happens next, and one thing to do this month

The open questions are specific and answerable. Does the apsidal temple's dating hold under further excavation? Do the pilgrimage routes between Lumbini and Tilaurakot produce material that ties the two sites into a single devotional landscape in the Mauryan period, as survey work along the old road already hints with its wells, rest stops and hoards of punch-marked silver coins? None of this will produce a birth certificate. All of it narrows the gap between a building and a man.

If you take one thing from this, take the habit of asking what a headline actually dated. Next time you read that scientists have revealed the origins of Buddhism, ask two questions: which site, and which dating technique. The Antiquity paper and the UNESCO Lumbini project record are both readable in under an hour, and they will make you a sharper reader of every claim that follows. That is a small step, and a worthwhile one for this month.

  • Buddhism origins
  • Lumbini
  • Tilaurakot
  • archaeology
  • Siddhartha Gautama
Porträt von Dr. Sophia Langford
Über den Autor

Dr. Sophia LangfordAutor ansehen

Academic Jobs In House Author

Sophia Langford is a Contributing Writer at AcademicJobs, empowering academic careers with her focus on faculty development and career guidance. With an EdD from Columbia University, she is a renowned consultant in acad…

Diskussionen

Sort von:

Seien Sie der Erste, der diesen Artikel kommentiert!

Du bist

Sie werden gebeten, sich anzumelden, bevor Ihr Kommentar veröffentlicht wird.

Browse nach Fakultät

Browse nach Thema

Frequently Asked Questions

🧭Who actually began Buddhism?

Buddhist tradition and the bulk of historical scholarship point to Siddhartha Gautama, a member of the Shakya clan born in the Lumbini garden in what is now southern Nepal. He taught in the Gangetic plain of northern India, and his followers formed the community that became the Sangha. The word Buddhism, however, was coined in Europe in the 1820s, so the religion as a named category has a separate and much later origin.

⏳When did Buddhism begin?

The strongest archaeological anchor is the timber shrine excavated at Lumbini, dated to about 550 BC using radiocarbon analysis of charcoal and optically stimulated luminescence on sand. That places the site's ritual use in the sixth century BC, at least three centuries earlier than the Asokan structures previously thought to be the oldest Buddhist remains anywhere.

🗿What did archaeologists find under the Maya Devi Temple?

The team led by Robin Coningham of Durham University and Kosh Prasad Acharya found postholes from a timber railing surrounding an unroofed central space with mineralised tree roots, plus clay floors worn smooth by visitors. Below that lay an earlier brick structure, and above it the third-century BC temple built under the emperor Ashoka. The findings were published in the journal Antiquity in December 2013.

🔎How did scientists date the shrine at Lumbini?

Two independent methods were applied to different materials. Charcoal fragments from the postholes were radiocarbon dated, returning a range of roughly 800 to 545 BC. Grains of sand were dated by optically stimulated luminescence, which measures when sediment was last exposed to light. Both approaches pointed to the sixth century BC.

🗓Does the 550 BC date prove when the Buddha was born?

No. The excavation dates a structure and the ritual activity around it, not a person's birth. Coningham himself said the team had a shrine pointing to the sixth century BC, while acknowledging that questions would remain. The find makes a sixth-century lifetime plausible and pushes against the argument that the Buddha lived as late as the third century BC.

🏛Who led the Lumbini excavations?

The work was co-directed by Robin Coningham, professor of archaeology at Durham University and later UNESCO Chair on Archaeological Ethics and Practice in Cultural Heritage, and Kosh Prasad Acharya of Nepal's Pashupati Area Development Trust. It ran under a UNESCO project funded by the Japanese government, in partnership with Nepal's Department of Archaeology and the Lumbini Development Trust.

⚖Why do some scholars reject the Lumbini conclusions?

Critics raised two objections. The Oxford historian Richard Gombrich told reporters there was no evidence the earliest structure was a Buddhist shrine. Julia Shaw of University College London noted that tree worship was common across ancient Indian religions, so an early tree shrine at Lumbini could predate Buddhism and be unconnected to the historical Buddha. Lars Fogelin of the University of Arizona disagreed, calling Buddhist affiliation the most likely reading.

📚Was Buddhism a religion before the word existed?

Practices, monasteries, texts and pilgrimage existed for more than two thousand years before anyone used the term. The word appears in French writing as early as 1817 and in English with Edward Upham's book of 1829, with the spelling settling in the 1860s. Eugène Burnouf's Introduction à l'histoire du buddhisme indien, published in 1844, gave European readers their first detailed critical account.

📜What are the Gandharan Buddhist scrolls?

They are the oldest surviving substantial collection of Buddhist manuscripts, acquired by the British Library in 1994. The 29 birch-bark scrolls were written in the Gandhari language using Kharosthi script and buried in a clay pot, and they date to roughly the first century AD. They include sutras, commentaries, verse collections and an early Dharmapada. You can read about the collection through the University of Washington project.

🪔What was discovered at Tilaurakot in 2026?

Nepal's Department of Archaeology, the Lumbini Development Trust and Durham University's UNESCO Chair announced the country's first apsidal Buddhist temple, a structure with a curved rear wall and an entrance platform opposite. It dates to between the third and fifth centuries AD and was built inside a monastery courtyard over the ruins of an earlier palace complex, with an earlier stupa enshrined within it.

🌏Why did UNESCO defer Tilaurakot's World Heritage nomination?

At the 47th session in Paris in July 2025, the World Heritage Committee followed ICOMOS advice and deferred the nomination. The committee asked Nepal to complete the study of the apsidal temple with firmer dating, research the site's religious architecture further, and consider resubmitting as a boundary modification of the existing Lumbini property. ICOMOS also noted that Tilaurakot's identification with Kapilavastu is contested, with India promoting Piprahwa and Ganwaria instead.

🧘How many Buddhists are there, and how busy is Lumbini?

Reporting around the 2013 excavation put the global Buddhist population at roughly 500 million. Lumbini, inscribed as a World Heritage property in 1997, receives about a million pilgrims and visitors a year. Coningham estimated that annual pilgrim traffic into South Asia would reach 22 million within five years, a figure that underscores the conservation pressure on the site.

🚩What are the four main Buddhist pilgrimage sites?

They are Lumbini, where tradition says the Buddha was born; Bodh Gaya, where he attained enlightenment under a fig tree; Sarnath, where he preached his first sermon; and Kusinagara, where he died at the age of 80. The Buddha is recorded as recommending that followers visit Lumbini, and Chinese pilgrims described a shrine beside a tree there in the middle of the first millennium AD.