Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

Research Community Urges Preservation of MSCA Bottom-Up Approach in 2026-27 Horizon Europe Programme

Submit News
the big book of the year book
Photo by Karl Solano on Unsplash

Europe's Research Landscape and MSCA's Enduring Role

The Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions, known as MSCA, stand as one of the European Union's flagship programmes for supporting researcher mobility, training, and career development. Funded under Horizon Europe, MSCA has long emphasised a bottom-up approach, allowing researchers to propose projects driven by scientific excellence rather than predefined policy themes. This principle has enabled thousands of researchers across Europe and beyond to pursue innovative work in universities, research institutes, and industry partners.

In the context of the 2026-2027 work programme, concerns have emerged about potential shifts that could alter this foundational element. Leading organisations representing higher education and research institutions have come together to advocate for continuity in the programme's design.

Understanding the Bottom-Up Approach in MSCA

The bottom-up approach in MSCA means that funding calls remain open to all research disciplines and topics chosen by applicants themselves. Researchers at doctoral, postdoctoral, and more senior stages propose projects based on their expertise and curiosity, without mandatory alignment to specific European Commission priorities. This contrasts with top-down or directed programmes where calls are tailored to address immediate policy goals such as climate targets or industrial competitiveness.

Proponents argue that this flexibility fosters genuine scientific discovery and attracts top international talent to European institutions. It supports interdisciplinary work and allows emerging fields to develop organically. Many universities across Europe, from those in the League of European Research Universities to members of the Coimbra Group, rely on MSCA grants to strengthen their research capacity and international collaborations.

Proposed Changes in the 2026-2027 Draft Work Programme

The draft Horizon Europe work programme for 2026-2027 introduced elements of directionality in MSCA. This would involve steering certain calls toward predefined thematic areas aligned with broader EU political objectives. Such changes raised alarms among stakeholders who viewed them as a departure from the programme's core identity.

While the final adopted programme retains significant bottom-up components, the initial proposals prompted a coordinated response from the research community. The focus remains on ensuring that MSCA continues to prioritise investigator-driven research over short-term policy steering.

The Joint Statement from European Research Organisations

In June 2025, the European University Association issued a joint statement alongside numerous partner networks. The document explicitly calls for MSCA to remain bottom-up and free from policy directionality. It emphasises that instruments supporting investigator-driven research must be shielded from short-term political agendas.

The statement highlights the programme's track record in delivering excellent science and building human capital across the European Research Area. Signatories stress that maintaining this approach is essential for Europe's competitiveness in global research and innovation.

Key Organisations Behind the Advocacy Effort

The coalition includes a broad range of bodies representing diverse segments of the European research ecosystem. The Young European Research Universities Network, the European Consortium of Innovative Universities, and the League of European Research Universities are among the endorsers. Additional support comes from the European Council of Doctoral Candidates and Junior Researchers, the Marie Curie Alumni Association, and the European Federation of Academies of Sciences and Humanities.

These groups collectively represent universities, research-performing organisations, academies, and early-career researchers. Their unified voice underscores the widespread consensus on preserving MSCA's distinctive features.

great value english breakfast tea bags

Photo by Karl Solano on Unsplash

Implications for Universities and Researchers Across Europe

For higher education institutions, MSCA funding supports doctoral training networks, postdoctoral fellowships, staff exchanges, and co-funded programmes. A shift toward greater directionality could limit opportunities for researchers in fields not aligned with immediate priorities, potentially affecting recruitment and retention strategies at universities in countries such as Germany, France, the Netherlands, and Italy.

Early-career researchers, in particular, benefit from the mobility and training opportunities that MSCA provides. Preserving the bottom-up nature ensures that talented individuals from varied backgrounds can contribute to frontier research without thematic constraints.

Stakeholder Perspectives on Programme Design

University leaders and research managers have expressed that the bottom-up model complements other parts of Horizon Europe, such as the mission-oriented clusters in Pillar II. MSCA's flexibility allows it to address emerging challenges through researcher initiative rather than centralised direction.

Alumni networks and doctoral candidate organisations note that the programme's openness has helped attract and retain talent within Europe, countering brain drain to other regions. They advocate for continued emphasis on excellence and mobility as core values.

Developments Following the Advocacy

The Horizon Europe work programme for 2026-2027 was ultimately adopted with substantial bottom-up elements retained in MSCA calls. Funding opportunities announced for 2026 include support for doctoral networks and postdoctoral fellowships that continue to operate on an open basis across disciplines.

Calls for proposals have proceeded with budgets exceeding €1.25 billion for the initial year, reflecting ongoing commitment to researcher development. Information days and guidance materials from the European Commission highlight the programme's role in excellent science.

Broader Context Within Horizon Europe

MSCA forms part of Pillar I, focused on excellent science alongside the European Research Council and research infrastructures. This pillar contrasts with the challenge-driven clusters in Pillar II and the innovation-focused Pillar III. Maintaining distinct characteristics across pillars helps ensure a balanced European research and innovation system.

Discussions around the 2026-2027 period also touch on participation rules for associated countries and the integration of social sciences and humanities, areas where bottom-up flexibility has proven valuable.

Looking Ahead to Future Framework Programmes

As preparations begin for the period beyond 2027, the research community continues to emphasise the importance of bottom-up funding mechanisms. The experience with MSCA in the current cycle provides lessons on balancing policy relevance with scientific autonomy.

European institutions, including the European Commission and member state representatives, engage regularly with stakeholder networks to refine programme design. The advocacy effort demonstrates the active role that universities and research organisations play in shaping the future of European research funding.

Pioneering research focuses on the path to agi.

Photo by Planet Volumes on Unsplash

Practical Steps for Researchers and Institutions

Universities and individual researchers interested in MSCA opportunities can consult the official calls on the Funding and Tenders Portal. Guidance emphasises proposal quality, mobility plans, and training elements regardless of specific thematic focus.

Networking through organisations such as the Marie Curie Alumni Association or national contact points can provide additional support for preparing competitive applications. Institutions often host information sessions to help potential applicants navigate the process.

Portrait of Prof. Marcus Blackwell

Prof. Marcus BlackwellView full profile

Contributing Writer

Shaping the future of academia with expertise in research methodologies and innovation.

Discussion

Sort by:

Be the first to comment on this article!

You

Please keep comments respectful and on-topic.

New0 comments

Join the conversation!

Add your comments now!

Have your say

Engagement level

Browse by Faculty

Browse by Subject

Frequently Asked Questions

🔬What is the MSCA bottom-up approach?

The bottom-up approach allows researchers to propose projects in any discipline based on scientific excellence, without mandatory alignment to specific policy themes.

⚠️Why are organisations concerned about changes in 2026-2027?

Draft proposals included elements of directionality that could steer calls toward predefined EU priorities, potentially limiting flexibility for investigator-driven research.

🤝Which organisations signed the joint statement?

The European University Association led the effort, joined by LERU, the Guild, Eurodoc, MCAA, and many other networks representing universities and researchers across Europe.

🏛️How does MSCA support European universities?

MSCA funds doctoral training, postdoctoral fellowships, and staff exchanges that enhance research capacity, international mobility, and talent attraction at institutions throughout Europe.

💰What is the budget for MSCA in 2026?

The 2026 calls include over €1.25 billion to support researcher training and mobility across the European Research Area.

📝How can researchers apply for MSCA funding?

Applications are submitted through the EU Funding and Tenders Portal, with calls for postdoctoral fellowships and doctoral networks open on a bottom-up basis.

🌱What are the benefits of bottom-up research funding?

It promotes scientific curiosity, enables emerging fields to develop, and attracts diverse talent by avoiding rigid thematic restrictions.

📊How does MSCA fit within Horizon Europe?

MSCA belongs to Pillar I on excellent science, complementing challenge-driven work in other pillars while maintaining its distinctive researcher-led character.

🔄What happens if directionality increases in future programmes?

Greater top-down steering could reduce opportunities in non-priority fields and affect the programme's ability to support frontier research and early-career mobility.

ℹ️Where can institutions find more information on MSCA?

Official details are available on the Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions website and the European Commission's research and innovation portal.