Every winter, farmers in northwest India, particularly in Punjab and Haryana, set fire to rice stubble left after harvest to quickly clear fields for the wheat crop. This practice, known as stubble burning, has long been recognized for choking cities like Delhi with toxic smog. A groundbreaking study published in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics and highlighted in Nature India confirms a previously underappreciated consequence: these fires are making the region hotter. Researchers from Banaras Hindu University analyzed five years of satellite data from 2017 to 2021, revealing that stubble burning raises land surface temperatures by an average of 0.57°C (95% confidence interval: 0.33–0.81°C) in heavily affected areas.
This warming effect stems from the intense heat released during burning—measured as fire radiative power (FRP)—combined with black carbon aerosols that absorb sunlight, outweighing the cooling from light-scattering particles. A shallow planetary boundary layer, averaging just 71 meters, traps this heat and smoke near the ground, amplifying the impact. The study's use of advanced methods like Random Forest modeling and geographically weighted regression isolated fire effects from weather and terrain variables, providing robust evidence of this climate feedback loop.
Understanding Stubble Burning in Northwest India
Stubble burning (full form: crop residue burning) occurs primarily after the rice (paddy) harvest in October-November, when farmers burn leftover stalks to prepare soil for wheat sowing. Punjab and Haryana, the breadbasket of India, generate massive rice residues—about 20 million tons annually—due to short-turnaround cropping cycles driven by water-intensive paddy cultivation. The process releases black carbon (BC), organic carbon, PM2.5, and greenhouse gases. While BC was once thought to have a net cooling effect via scattering, recent analyses show absorption dominates, contributing to positive radiative forcing (warming).
Land surface temperature (LST) data from MODIS satellites showed positive correlations: higher FRP linked to elevated LST and aerosol optical depth (AOD). In the intensive fire zone (29.3–32.2°N, 73.9–77.1°E), fires peaked in November with FRP ~310,000 MW/month. This biophysical perturbation—direct heating plus aerosol trapping—exacerbates local warming amid already rising regional temperatures.
Key Findings from the Banaras Hindu University Study
The research by Akanksha Pandey and colleagues at Banaras Hindu University's Institute of Environment & Sustainable Development used multi-satellite datasets: MODIS for LST and FRP, VIIRS for fires, MERRA-2 for AOD and PBLH. Key stats:
- ΔLST: 0.57°C increase post-fire (varies 0.33–0.76°C yearly).
- ΔAOD: 0.13 (0.07–0.22).
- FRP as top LST predictor (importance 0.22–0.40), PBLH second (0.21–0.24), AOD third (0.09–0.11).
- Hurst exponents >0.5 indicate persistent fire-LST-AOD patterns.
"FRP consistently emerged as the dominant predictor of LST," the authors note, with non-linear effects saturating at high intensities. Spatial heterogeneity via GWR showed stronger warming centrally. Models (R²=0.65–0.75) confirm fires' role beyond pollution.
This challenges models underestimating fire-climate links, urging updates for better projections. For higher education, such studies highlight research opportunities at institutions like BHU; explore research jobs in environmental science.
Trends in Stubble Burning Incidents: Progress and Challenges
Fire counts have plummeted due to policies: Punjab's 2025 paddy season saw 5,114 incidents (93% drop from 2021 peak), Haryana 662 (lowest in 5 years). CAQM credits enforcement, subsidies for machinery. Yet, wheat stubble burning (April-May) persists: Punjab >10,200, Haryana 1,832 in 2025. Timing shifts to afternoons evade polar satellites, undercounting by 25-35% burnt area.
CAQM's 2026 statutory direction mandates farm mapping, nodal officers, rent-free residue machines in Punjab, Haryana, UP. Supreme Court-mandated expert reports emphasize coordinated action.
Beyond Smog: Health and Climate Implications
Stubble smoke causes 44,000–98,000 premature deaths yearly from PM exposure. Black carbon accelerates Himalayan glacier melt, alters monsoons. Net warming from BC (460-1500x CO2 potency short-term) compounds +0.6°C LST rise, stressing water-scarce agriculture. Delhi AQI spikes to 'severe', respiratory cases surge 3-fold.
Experts like Tirthankar Banerjee (BHU) stress: "Precise accounting could guide policies."Read the full Nature highlight. University researchers drive solutions; check India higher ed jobs.
Photo by Abdulaziz Alfawzan on Unsplash
Mechanisms of Warming: Black Carbon and Fire Heat
Stubble emits BC-rich smoke; absorption heats atmosphere, reduces surface cooling. FRP (energy release) directly warms soil/air. Shallow PBLH limits dispersion, enhancing trapping. Studies confirm positive direct radiative forcing (DRF) from ag-BC in India. Unlike sulfate cooling aerosols, BC's warming dominates post-monsoon.
Government Policies and 2026 Roadmap
National Clean Air Programme, crop residue schemes subsidize machinery (₹Rs. 1,700 crore 2025). CAQM's GRAP stages ban burning, enforce alternatives. 2026 wheat plan: village-level monitoring, protection forces, bio-decomposers. Punjab's DBT blocks subsidies for burners.
Success: 90% paddy fire drop 2025 via custom hiring centers (3,000+ machines).CAQM site.
Promising Alternatives: Case Studies and Economics
Happy Seeder (direct wheat seeding in residue) boosts yield 6.8%, cuts costs ₹600/ha, GHG 78%. Punjab adoption rose; 2025 trials profitable vs. burning. Takachar converts stubble to biochar/fuels, farmer income +₹10,000/ha.
- Composting: Pusa decomposer (IARI) microbial spray; 2-week breakdown.
- Bioenergy: Punjab biomass plants consume 2M tons/year.
- Mulching: Improves soil moisture 20-30%, yields +10%.
Challenges: upfront costs (₹Happy Seeder ₹5-7 lakh, subsidized 50-80%), termite fears. Custom service centers key; PAU Ludhiana trains farmers. Research at PAU, BHU drives innovation—see research assistant jobs.
Stakeholder Perspectives: Farmers, Experts, Policymakers
Farmers cite time crunch (10-15 days window), machinery access. Experts (Gullberg, IIM-Amritsar): cash incentives viable. CAQM Chair: "No ego in pollution fight." BHU's Banerjee: integrate fire effects in models. Multi-perspective: balance livelihoods, environment.
Role of Higher Education and Research Institutions
BHU's study exemplifies university-led solutions. IIT Kanpur models dispersion, PAU Ludhiana develops seeder variants. ICAR subsidizes trials. Future: AI monitoring (ISRO), biotech decomposers. Aspiring researchers, view faculty positions or scholarships.
Photo by Rach Cohen on Unsplash
Future Outlook: Towards Zero Burning by 2030?
With 2026 wheat plans, machine banks, incentives, elimination feasible. Scale Happy Seeder to 50% adoption: save 10M tons CO2-eq/year, cool region. Monitor via geostationary satellites (INSAT-3DR). Balanced view: enforce + incentivize. Explore higher ed career advice for sustainability roles, higher ed jobs, rate my professor.
India's stubble challenge offers climate action model, blending tech, policy, research.
.png&w=128&q=75)
