How do you handle a reviewer who disputes your coding scheme?

Created byJarrod Kanizay AvatarJarrod KanizayApplied Linguistics

0 hearts0 comments0 replies

I recently had a paper returned where one reviewer questioned the reliability of my coding scheme for classroom interaction data.

I had reported inter-rater agreement, but they wanted more detail on how categories were defined and revised.

I'm curious how others respond when a reviewer challenges the methodological core of a qualitative study.

What has worked for you in a response letter?

Comments

No comments yet.