How do you handle reviewers who demand more field data?

Created byJarrod Kanizay AvatarJarrod KanizayGeophysics

0 hearts0 comments0 replies

I recently had a paper returned with reviewers asking for additional field measurements that would take another season to collect.

The existing dataset already supports the main conclusions, but I'm unsure how hard to push back.

How do you decide when to argue against a reviewer's request for more data versus when to just go collect it?

Comments

No comments yet.