Tertiary Education Reform: Calls Intensify for Independent ATEC to Oversee Australia's Higher Education Sector

Australia's tertiary education sector stands at a pivotal moment. With over 1.5 million students enrolled across more than 40 universities and other higher education providers, the system plays a crucial role in workforce development, research innovation, and regional economic growth. Valued at approximately $38.8 billion in 2026, it educates future nurses, engineers, teachers, and researchers while generating significant export revenue through international students, who numbered around 300,000 pre-caps. Yet, persistent policy volatility, funding uncertainties, and governance challenges have prompted urgent calls for reform, centered on establishing a robust independent oversight body: the Australian Tertiary Education Commission (ATEC).

The push for ATEC emerges from the Australian Universities Accord, a landmark 2022-2024 review—the most comprehensive in 15 years—that diagnosed chronic instability in policy and funding. Recommendation 30 proposed ATEC as an apolitical steward to provide evidence-based advice on long-term needs, shielding the sector from short-term political shifts. Interim ATEC launched on July 1, 2025, led by acting commissioners Professor Barney Glover AO, The Hon Fiona Nash, and Professor Tom Calma AO, but full statutory independence hinges on pending legislation moving through Parliament as of February 2026.

The Origins of Reform: Universities Accord and Systemic Challenges

The Universities Accord process, initiated in November 2022, gathered input from stakeholders nationwide to envision a 'future made in Australia.' Its final report highlighted how frequent policy flips—such as the Job-ready Graduates scheme—led to a 10% drop in low-income bachelor's enrolments from 2020 to 2024, with steeper declines in humanities, arts, and social sciences (HASS) fields at 21%. Regional and remote students remain underrepresented at 20-25% of enrolments despite comprising 27% of the population, while First Nations students hover at 2.3% versus 3.8% nationally.

Funding pressures exacerbate these issues. Government subsidies have declined relative to costs, pushing reliance on international fees, which surged post-pandemic but now face caps at 270,000-295,000 commencements for 2025-2026 amid housing strains. Research funding lags full economic costs, stifling commercialization. ATEC aims to coordinate these strands, fostering stability for institutions to plan multi-year strategies.

What Would ATEC Do? Core Functions and Structure

Envisioned as a statutory authority akin to the Productivity Commission, ATEC would offer independent advice on skills pipelines, research investment, attainment targets (aiming for 80% of 25-34-year-olds with tertiary qualifications), and data unification. It would negotiate mission-based compacts with providers to align with national priorities like net-zero transitions and AI ethics, while monitoring financial sustainability and equity.

The proposed structure includes three commissioners with deep sector expertise—one potentially focused on First Nations perspectives. Unlike the current Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency (TEQSA), which enforces compliance and quality standards, ATEC focuses on strategic stewardship, proactive inquiries, and public reporting. This division ensures TEQSA handles regulation while ATEC drives vision.

• Provide frank, evidence-led reports on workforce gaps, e.g., nursing shortages projected at 100,000 by 2030.
• Centralize fragmented data from Department of Education, NCVER, and providers for better decision-making.
• Convene stakeholders, including Learned Academies, for multidisciplinary insights into emerging fields like quantum computing.

Independence Under Fire: Critiques of the Current Bill

While the Bill enshrines a National Tertiary Education Objective—bolstering democracy, economy, and sustainability—stakeholders decry its dilution of independence. Universities Australia Chair Professor Carolyn Evans argued in The Australian that limits on commissioners (two full-time, one part-time), ministerial vetoes on inquiries and publications, and staffing via public servants risk turning ATEC into a departmental extension. Over 50 Senate submissions echo this, with Western Sydney University warning of curtailed autonomy and RMIT lamenting a 'missed generational opportunity.'

Government counters that legislation guarantees direct ministerial reporting, research powers, and independent reviews after two and five years. Minister Jason Clare emphasizes balance: policy direction from elected officials, expertise from ATEC.

Photo by Trnava University on Unsplash

Stakeholder Voices: Support and Pushback

Universities Australia urges modeling ATEC on the Productivity Commission's transparent inquiries, enabling arm's-length advice for productivity gains. The Australian Academy of the Humanities advocates proactive evidence-gathering, leveraging academies' expertise in HASS to address gaps in languages and civic education. Regional groups like IRU seek broader commissioner roles for diverse providers.

Conversely, Independent Tertiary Education Council Australia (ITECA) fears added bureaucracy for non-university providers. Staff unions highlight governance overlaps with the Expert Council on University Governance's October 2025 principles, emphasizing accountability and inclusivity amid staff discontent.

For a balanced view, the Bill's Senate inquiry reports by February 26, 2026, could prompt amendments like expanded commissions and hiring freedoms.

The Productivity Commission Blueprint: Lessons for Success

Australia's Productivity Commission exemplifies effective independence: rigorous public inquiries yield trusted reforms, from competition policy to aged care. ATEC could emulate this by commissioning sector-wide audits, publishing without veto, and staffing with academics, industry experts, and economists. This would counter volatility, like 20+ policy shifts in a decade, stabilizing enrolments and investment.

Real-World Impacts: Students, Staff, and Economy

Independent oversight promises equity gains: reversing Job-ready declines via reformed pricing, boosting regional hubs like Regional University Study Hubs (RUSH). Students benefit from reliable data for course choices, while universities plan research without funding cliffs. Economically, aligned skills address shortages in renewables and health, potentially adding billions in productivity.

Challenges persist: international caps risk $10bn revenue shortfalls, straining budgets. Staff-to-student ratios at ~20:1 highlight casualization issues, with new laws capping fixed-term contracts by 2025.

Governance Synergies: TEQSA, Expert Council, and Beyond

ATEC complements TEQSA's regulatory role, which recently strengthened via Lynelle Briggs AO-led reviews. The Expert Council's eight principles—accountability, diversity, transparency—guide university councils, addressing staff safety and representation. Together, they form a layered framework: strategic (ATEC), quality (TEQSA), internal (councils).

Photo by Sichen Xiang on Unsplash

• Step 1: ATEC sets national targets.
• Step 2: TEQSA enforces standards.
• Step 3: Providers implement via compacts.

Future Outlook: Pathways to a Stronger Sector

If strengthened, ATEC could unify data, predict trends like AI-driven course needs, and foster public trust. Pre-budget submissions urge $44m outreach funding from 2026. Challenges include fiscal pressures and election cycles, but cross-party support signals momentum.

For professionals, reforms spotlight opportunities in policy, research, and administration. Check Australian academic roles or career advice to navigate changes.

Actionable Insights for Stakeholders

Universities: Engage Senate inquiries for amendments. Policymakers: Prioritize independence for longevity. Students: Advocate via unions. Aspiring academics: Build expertise in equity, data analytics. With thoughtful reform, Australia's tertiary sector can deliver sustainable prosperity.

Discover openings at university jobs, rate experiences on Rate My Professor, or seek higher ed career advice.