Canadian Study Reveals How COVID-19 Lockdowns Masked Child Maltreatment Detection

Unmasking the Shadows: A Landmark Canadian Study on Child Maltreatment During COVID-19 Lockdowns

The COVID-19 pandemic brought unprecedented challenges to public health systems worldwide, but few issues highlight its hidden toll as starkly as child maltreatment detection during lockdowns. A groundbreaking study published today in the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) reveals that hospital admissions for maltreatment among children younger than 2 years plummeted by 31% during the initial 16-week lockdown period in Canada. This drop, researchers argue, did not reflect a decrease in abuse but rather a masking effect due to restricted access to healthcare and the closure of schools—key venues for early detection. 82 40

Lead researcher Dr. Matthew Carwana, a pediatrician affiliated with the BC Children's Hospital Research Institute at the University of British Columbia (UBC), led a team from the Pediatric Outcomes Improvement Through Coordination of Research Networks (POPCORN). Their findings underscore a critical vulnerability in child protection systems during crises, prompting calls for robust detection mechanisms in future emergencies. This research, rooted in collaborative efforts across Canadian pediatric centers and universities, emphasizes the vital role of academic institutions in safeguarding vulnerable populations.

Understanding Child Maltreatment: Definitions and Prevalence in Canada

Child maltreatment encompasses physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, neglect, and exposure to intimate partner violence (IPV). In Canada, these forms of harm affect a significant portion of the population. Recent self-reported data from over 5,000 Canadian youth aged 15 and older indicate that 32.5% experienced emotional abuse, 22.3% physical abuse, and 5.3% sexual abuse before age 15. Neglect rates hover around 5.2%, highlighting a persistent public health crisis. 50

Pre-pandemic statistics from the Ontario Incidence Study of Reported Child Abuse and Neglect (OIS-2023), conducted by researchers at McMaster University and other institutions, showed over 100,000 investigations annually in Ontario alone. Nationally, child protection services handle hundreds of thousands of reports each year, with schools serving as the primary source—mandatory reporters who observe behavioral and physical signs daily. When schools shuttered in March 2020, this frontline detection network vanished, creating a blind spot.

The term "sentinel injuries" refers to seemingly minor injuries like bruises or fractures in non-mobile infants that signal potential abuse. Hospitals traditionally investigate these to prevent escalation. The CMAJ study focused on such admissions, revealing how lockdowns disrupted this process step-by-step: first, parental hesitancy to seek non-emergency care; second, reduced routine check-ups; third, overwhelmed emergency departments prioritizing COVID cases.

Deep Dive into the CMAJ Study: Methodology and Nationwide Scope

The study analyzed hospital data from approximately 750,000 children under 2 years across all Canadian provinces and territories. Researchers compared prepandemic admissions (April 2016–February 2020) with pandemic-era data (March 2020–March 2023), sourcing from the Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) for most regions and Quebec's INESSS database. Over the full period, 1,518 admissions qualified as maltreatment-related sentinel injuries. 82

• Data Granularity: Population-based discharge abstracts coded for abuse indicators.
• Lockdown Window: First 16 weeks (roughly March–June 2020), coinciding with strict stay-at-home orders.
• Controls: Adjusted for seasonal variations and population growth.

This rigorous approach, involving statisticians and epidemiologists from UBC and partner universities, ensures reliability. For those pursuing careers in pediatric research, opportunities abound in networks like POPCORN—check out research assistant jobs at Canadian universities to contribute to similar impactful work.

Key Findings: A 31% Drop and an 80% ICU Surge

The most alarming statistic: a 31% reduction in overall hospital admissions during the lockdown, followed by a return to baseline. More concerning, intensive care unit (ICU) admissions for maltreatment rose 80% immediately after restrictions eased. This pattern suggests children endured undetected harm, presenting later with life-threatening injuries like abusive head trauma or severe fractures. 82

Dr. Carwana noted, "Young children experiencing maltreatment... did not appear to present to care during the period of restricted health care access." This delay likely amplified severity, as early intervention via sentinel injury assessments prompts child welfare involvement.

Explore faculty positions in public health at Canadian higher ed jobs to advance such analyses.

Photo by Andy Holmes on Unsplash

Why the Masking Effect? Schools, Stress, and Systemic Gaps

Schools report up to 50% of maltreatment cases in normal times, per Public Health Agency of Canada data. Lockdowns eliminated this, while household stressors—job loss, confinement, parental mental health declines—likely rose. A University of Toronto study found parental anxiety spiked 40% early in the pandemic, correlating with abuse risks.

Virtual healthcare, while innovative, proved inadequate for visual inspections needed for sentinel injuries. Pediatricians at the Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids, University of Toronto) reported challenges in remote assessments. 43

Cultural contexts in Indigenous and low-income communities exacerbated risks, with limited access compounding issues. For comprehensive career advice on child welfare research, visit higher ed career advice.

Post-Lockdown Realities: Case Studies and Broader Trends

Following lockdowns, referrals rebounded, but severity increased. In British Columbia, child welfare data showed a 20% rise in substantiated severe cases by 2021. Real-world examples include delayed fracture detections leading to repeat admissions.

Nationally, the Canadian Incidence Study (CIS) at McGill University documented fluctuating reports, with a 7-10% overall dip masked by underreporting. 0 Recent 2025-2026 prevalence studies confirm ongoing high rates, urging sustained vigilance.

AcademicJobs.com lists university jobs in Canada focused on social sciences and health.

Stakeholder Perspectives: From Pediatricians to Policymakers

Experts like Dr. Nico Trocmé from McGill's School of Social Work emphasize integrated surveillance. "Pandemic gaps exposed the need for multi-sector data sharing," he stated in related publications. Child welfare workers reported 64% adoption of virtual tools but persistent referral drops. 42

• Healthcare Providers: Advocated for hybrid check-ins.
• Educators: Pushed for virtual reporting protocols.
• Government: Public Health Agency recommends framework enhancements.

Indigenous leaders highlight culturally safe interventions. For postdoc opportunities, see postdoc positions.

Implications for Policy and Public Health Preparedness

The study advocates for lockdown-resilient detection: mandatory virtual school screenings, hotline expansions, and AI-flagged pediatric calls. British Columbia's enhanced protocols post-study exemplify proactive steps.

Long-term, integrating child maltreatment surveillance into national health data (as proposed in 2021 PHAC reports) could prevent repeats. Investments in university-led research, like UBC's POPCORN, are crucial. 46

Photo by Donovan Dean Photography on Unsplash

Future Outlook: University Research Driving Solutions

Canadian universities continue leading: University of Waterloo models predictive analytics for at-risk families; Concordia University studies snow drought's indirect family stress links. Horizon 2030 funding prioritizes child resilience post-COVID.

Join the forefront via professor jobs or lecturer jobs in child health fields.

Actionable Insights and Calls to Action

Parents: Recognize sentinel signs like unexplained bruises; use resources like Kids Help Phone. Professionals: Train in virtual detection. Policymakers: Fund university research hubs.

Rate professors contributing to this field at Rate My Professor, explore higher ed jobs, and access career advice. For university positions, visit university jobs and consider posting at post a job.