At a glance
Universities blame the ATS for slow hiring. The evidence points to handoffs, unowned steps and committee drift, and the fixes cost less than new software.
The question I keep hearing from university partners goes some version of this: we spent two years and a great deal of money replacing our ageing HR system, so why does hiring still feel like passing paper down a corridor?
The campus usually got what it paid for. Workday Recruiting, the hiring module inside Workday's human capital management platform, does receive applications, route approvals and hold the audit trail. What still snags is the space between the steps. A requisition parked in a compensation queue for nine days. A panel whose members were never asked to hold a date. A candidate who uploads a transcript into one system and is asked for it again somewhere else.
That is what hiring managers mean by friction, and it's worth being precise about, because "our system is bad" leads to a procurement conversation when the useful conversation is about handoffs.
An applicant tracking system is a filing cabinet with a legal memory
An applicant tracking system (ATS) is the software that receives applications, stores candidate materials and records the decisions made about each one. In a university it usually sits inside something larger, a human capital management (HCM) platform covering payroll, benefits and position management, or runs alongside one. Workday Recruiting is Workday's hiring module. Interfolio Faculty Search is a separate product built for academic searches and used at Georgetown, Yale and Arizona State, among other campuses.
Two jobs pull the same system in different directions. HR needs a defensible record: who applied, who was interviewed, who was set aside and on what basis. A faculty committee needs to read 140 CVs against a rubric and argue about a shortlist. Few products serve both, which is why so many campuses run staff hires through Workday and academic searches through a faculty-specific tool, then spend their energy on the seam between them.
At Georgetown, faculty hiring before 2017 ran on shared drives, email and three different platforms across ten schools. When a department made an offer, an administrator built a placeholder requisition in Workday that was never posted, created a dummy application for the chosen candidate, pushed it through the stages and then typed the biographical data by hand. Faculty Search now connects to Workday through an application programming interface (API), so a requisition created in Workday generates the Interfolio posting and the selected candidate's record flows back. "All of the applicant data is keyed into Interfolio by the applicant, and the data flows electronically to our Workday human resources system, so there's no re-keying of data," said Charlie Leonhardt, Georgetown's director of online initiatives and innovation.
Yale's version is less seamless and more candid about it. Its Faculty Search Reporting Process pulls from Interfolio on a cycle that can lag by up to an hour, so search chairs are told to finish every applicant status change before submitting a search for approval. Arizona State sends competitive academic searches through Faculty Search and routes waiver-of-recruitment hires straight into Workday. Different designs, one shared decision underneath: name where the authoritative record lives.
The fix that worked had nothing to do with the software
At the University of Alberta, hiring managers were asked what was wrong and gave answers that will sound familiar. Long waits. Too many hand-offs, to the point where nobody knew whom to contact. Too many entry points and forms. A KPMG review confirmed the diagnosis: the institution had been under-resourced in recruitment, and much of the load had landed on managers already stretched across their own teams. In February 2024 the university started a twelve-month pilot with four recruitment associates in Shared Services, whose remit runs from building an interview plan through reference checks, pre-hire setup and drafting the offer.
A dean in the Faculty of Arts described the difference in terms of sequencing: the associate took time to understand the role, then built a recruitment timeline that worked for the committee's schedules and kept the search moving. Nothing in that description involves new technology. It involves a person with a name and a remit.
The University of Minnesota reached a similar conclusion earlier and wrote it down. Its HR office produced a hiring service agreement that documented every step, assigned each one an owner and set expectations for completion; after a pilot across ten units, the agreement went campus-wide and time-to-hire fell by more than half.
Where that discipline is absent, the workaround is human and expensive. A vice president of HR at a public university in the Southwest, quoted in a study of high-efficiency HR departments, described the routine: "the hiring units would sit on the process without posting, and this held everything up. So now my staff spend each Monday morning calling every hiring unit to see if they've posted, reminding them what they have to do."
An external review of recruitment at the University of Oregon, published in 2018, put the underlying conflict more sharply. Interviewees described a process in which "every transaction is an audit," centralised in the name of risk control, while staff in the units said their gravest concern was losing a strong candidate because a form sat for weeks awaiting a box to be checked. The review's answer, push authority out to regional hubs and then train, trust and audit, is a governance remedy for a governance problem. Most "system" complaints turn out to be that.
Photo by Zulfugar Karimov on Unsplash
What the clock looks like, and why go-live didn't reset it
The University of Washington went live on Workday Recruiting in August 2025 after an eleven-month implementation, an unusually short runway, and its project team said so in public. Hiring managers were warned that "navigating routine tasks will be clunky at first" and that applicant job searches wouldn't rank results by relevance, so a query for "program coordinator" would return anything containing either word. The same update told the campus not to expect significant movement in department-level time-to-hire, because in a decentralised model the clock is set by how fast hiring managers review files, how long requisitions wait for approval, how screenings are booked and how offers clear.
That is the honest version of what a platform change delivers. CUPA-HR, the association for higher education human resources professionals, collects two measures and defines them precisely: time to fill runs from posting to offer acceptance, and time to hire runs from application to acceptance. Institutions report both by employee group, tenure-track faculty separately from staff, which is the only way either number means anything. For tenure-track roles in the United States, the association's Faculty in Higher Education Survey puts the median search at nine to twelve months from requisition to acceptance, with visa processing, salary negotiation and failed offers pushing some past a year.
The University of Florida's Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences publishes a stage-by-stage schedule that shows where those months sit.
| Stage of a faculty search | Published duration |
|---|---|
| Preliminary administrative approval | 1 week |
| Pre-search preparation | 2-4 weeks |
| Final administrative approval | 1-2 weeks |
| Advertising the position | 4-6 weeks |
| Candidate review and semi-finalist interviews | 2-6 weeks |
| Finalist interviews | 4-10 weeks |
| Researcher screening and offer | 1-2 weeks |
| Start date | 2-3 months, or the start of the semester |
Read that column and the arithmetic is unforgiving. Advertising alone eats four to six weeks, finalist interviews another four to ten, and the hire then needs two to three months before they can start, or waits for the semester boundary. Add two approval steps and the search is five months old before a single committee meeting has been held. The full schedule is published by UF/IFAS Human Resources.
The pattern repeats elsewhere. Yale School of Medicine tells faculty leaders to expect at least four to six months. UNSW Canberra, in a submission to an Australian parliamentary inquiry, reported that 102 academic recruitment processes over a twelve-month period ran past the four-month advertising limit, and those searches averaged 28 weeks from advertisement to offer acceptance. Academic notice periods in Australia can run to twelve months, which means the calendar for a February start begins the previous January.
Where search committees lose the weeks
Committee drift is usually blamed on training, and the evidence on training is thinner than the enthusiasm for it. A study of one institution's use of equity advocates, trained faculty and staff who sit on search committees outside their own departments, found that committee members credited the advocates with questioning assumptions and introducing standard tools for comparing candidates. The advocates themselves described a more contentious relationship with their committees and less confidence that the process was free of bias. Both groups agreed the role added something worth keeping. The research is in Innovative Higher Education.
Structured process does show up in outcomes. The University of Nevada, Reno School of Medicine required a two-hour workshop on search practice and bias for every committee from 2017; across 55 committees and 179 participants, 94 percent of mandatory practices were implemented, and the school recorded significant increases in the diversity of applicants, interviewees and offers in the three years that followed. Indiana University Indianapolis made equity-focused search training mandatory in 2023 and has reported early changes, while noting that attributing hiring outcomes to training needs longitudinal data.
What the training cannot fix is a committee that has no idea when its work is due. William & Mary's College of Arts & Sciences issues a search matrix each year with dates attached: the position is created in Workday in early September, the requisition follows eight days later, application review begins 30 to 45 days after posting, shortlist approvals land in the first week of December, campus interviews run from mid-January, and no offer letter goes out before the hiring justification reaches Faculty Personnel Services. The document is unglamorous and it is the reason those searches close on time. Somebody in that office builds it every summer for departments that would otherwise be guessing.
Candidate-facing detail belongs on the same page. If your application materials are being parsed by a machine before a person reads them, the guidance in how to write a winning academic CV applies to your institution's own instructions as much as to applicants. Ambiguous upload prompts, missing document types and unexplained rejection codes all generate email that a coordinator then answers one at a time.
Same hire, three different rhythms
Australian universities advertise academic roles for four to eight weeks, sometimes twelve, and then work within labour market testing rules that cap the window between advertising and nomination. That combination produces the UNSW arithmetic above, and occasionally a re-advertisement of a role whose preferred candidate has already been identified.
Singapore's Nanyang Technological University, the first higher education institution in Asia to adopt Workday, consolidated 65 in-house HR applications into a single system. The operational consequence is less reconciliation: one record for a staff appointment instead of a dozen spreadsheets that each describe part of a person.
In Britain, the University of York signed for the platform and the University of Hull went live on it; Melbourne and Auckland did the same in their markets. RMIT reports 60 real-time integrations across upstream and downstream systems and a 50 percent reduction in turnaround time for hiring, job changes and terminations. Workday puts its higher education customer base at more than 650 institutions in 19 countries.
None of these arrangements is wrong. Each encodes a view about who is trusted to decide and how much variance a campus can tolerate. What travels badly is the timetable. A schedule that reads as rigorous on one campus reads as neglect on another, and an international candidate compares you to the system they already work inside, not to your intentions. Candidates also form a view of the institution long before an offer exists, which is why employer branding in higher education tends to be settled by the application portal rather than the recruitment video.
Photo by Annie Spratt on Unsplash
One page, one owner, this month
If a hiring team wants a single task to start on Monday, it's this: take one live search and draw it on a single page, from approval to signed offer, with a named person and a clock time beside every transition. Not a policy document. A map with names on it, showing who moves the file, how many working days they have, what finished looks like, and what the candidate is told while they wait.
Minnesota's service agreement is that page. Alberta's recruitment associates are that page with staff attached. William & Mary's matrix is that page with dates attached. Give a copy to the search chair and to the person in the provost's office who chases the disposition codes, then rewrite it in plain language for the candidate.
The campuses that fill difficult roles fastest aren't the wealthiest ones. They're the ones where somebody can answer, without opening a screen, who has the file right now.
- Workday Recruiting
- higher education hiring
- ATS integration
- search committee best practices
- time to hire

