Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

Internal Mobility in Higher Education: Filling Gaps With the People You Already Employ

11 min read0 Ansichten

At a glance

A practical guide for TA and career development leaders on moving researchers, lecturers and professional staff across departments — with a checklist and the numbers to report.

People walking and sitting near a modern building with large glass windows
Photo by Yue WU on Unsplash

A capable person, told to stay put

The professional staff member I keep thinking about was, by her manager's own account, capable. When she raised what she wanted next, the answer she got was a version of this: "I've been identified as someone that's capable, but in terms of my career aspirations that has not really been acknowledged or hasn't been fostered or empowered. It's been very much 'we'll keep you in this position, because that's where you're best placed.'" She said it in a focus group conducted for the University of Sydney's SAGE Silver application, alongside colleagues who described internal vacancies that never reached the internal site and interviews that went to people already known to the hiring manager.

Her position is not a personality problem. It is what a default system produces. Internal mobility — the movement of people already on the payroll into different roles, levels, teams or projects, whether by promotion, lateral transfer, secondment, job swap or a fixed-term project placement — is the least expensive way a university fills a gap, and one of the least used.

The numbers are blunt. In the 2025 Higher Education Employee Retention Survey run by the College and University Professional Association for Human Resources (CUPA-HR), one in four employees said they were likely or very likely to look for another job within the year, and more than half were at least somewhat likely. Among those considering a move, nearly half were open to a different role at their own institution. That is a large, trained, already-interviewed candidate pool sitting inside the building.

LinkedIn's 2025 Workplace Learning Report found that only 44% of organisations run an internal mobility programme at all, and that roughly one in five employees feel confident they could actually make an internal move where they work. The same research series has put the payoff at a 23% lift in internal mobility, a 57% lift in retention and a 27% increase in promotions into management for organisations with strong learning cultures. Confidence, it turns out, is a management output.

The procedure excludes the people who need it most

Read a secondment policy before you read a strategy. La Trobe University's Secondment Procedure states that continuing staff may apply, then rules out casual staff and staff on fixed-term appointments. The University of Adelaide's secondment register covers professional continuing and fixed-term staff and explicitly excludes academic and casual staff. Both documents are competently written. Both, by design, withhold the development tool from the groups with the least security and the most to gain.

Those groups are not marginal. Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA) figures for 2024/25 recorded 244,755 academic staff at UK providers on 1 December 2024, a fall of 1% and the first decline since 2014/15, with 29% on fixed-term contracts — 43% among part-time academics against 21% of full-time staff. For research-only staff the picture is starker: a 2025 analysis published in eLife, drawing on Vitae data, puts 13% of UK researchers on open-ended contracts and 64% on fixed-term deals, half of them lasting under two years.

A researcher on a two-year grant who is barred from a six-month secondment is being told, in policy language, that the institution has no interest in her third year. Another Sydney respondent, who joined on a fixed-term contract, said she hadn't realised there would be no continuing roles advertised once she arrived. Promises about career development don't survive that arithmetic.

A ladder is a spreadsheet before it is a promise

Where institutions have done this properly, they started with the dull part: classifying the jobs they already have. Kansas State University ran a compensation study that produced a staff job architecture — job families and subfamilies, two career streams for individual contributors and managers, pay grades benchmarked against 37 comparator institutions using CUPA-HR and industry survey data. Individual memos went to every staff member in the first phase, including those whose title and pay didn't change, and the university committed that no one's pay would fall as a result of the market determination. The structure is published; anyone can search a job family and see the rung above their own.

West Virginia University took a comparable route through six documented phases, from mapping the current state to building career ladders and title standards across all its campuses. Neither project is glamorous. Kansas State's study was scoped at 18 to 24 months. That timeline is the honest cost of making progression legible, and it's why so many institutions announce a mobility commitment and then quietly stop.

The K-State job architecture is worth reading not for its pay ranges but for its definitions: what separates a level I from a level II leadership role, what a business title may and may not claim. And the HESA staff statistics are worth reading alongside it, because they show how many people in your own institution are on contracts that a promotions framework built for permanent staff will never touch.

Research staff need a parallel track. The Researcher Development Concordat, which UK institutions sign voluntarily, sets a minimum of ten days a year for professional development and requires signatories to publish action plans and annual progress reports. Those ten days are the raw material of internal mobility. An institution that can't say how many of its researchers used them can't claim to be developing anybody.

Modern building with balconies and windows

Photo by Mike Hindle on Unsplash

Most movement is sideways

Promotion is the visible form of mobility and the rarest. The volume sits in lateral moves: a technician into a research facility role, an administrator into a faculty operations post, a postdoc into a research development team. Deakin University frames fixed-term vacancies as potential secondments for existing staff, with the manager's support, which is a small procedural sentence with large consequences for how a vacancy gets read.

Keele University's proposed Talent Exchange goes further on paper: a university-wide programme of job swaps, short placements, project assignments, secondments and job shadowing open to professional services and technical staff at every grade, with voluntary year-long swaps as the flagship. Participants keep their substantive posts. The proposal's own diagnosis is the part worth stealing: staff develop deep expertise in one department, can't show breadth, and conclude they must leave the university to get promoted, even when they'd rather stay.

For early-career researchers, the sideways move is often the one that keeps them in the sector. A postdoc who spends six months in a research institute's partnerships team, or takes a teaching-focused contract with a route back to research, is being retained by structure rather than sentiment. The practical mechanics of that transition — how to present a portfolio career on paper — are covered in this guide to postdoctoral success, which is a useful thing to hand a researcher before the conversation rather than after it.

Managers are measured on what they keep

Here is the honest obstacle. A head of school is accountable for output, not for the career of the person who produces it, and releasing a strong staff member for a year looks like a self-inflicted wound. The Keele proposal names the pattern directly: talented employees get treated as a departmental resource rather than a university resource. One Sydney respondent, a manager herself, described "a lack of opportunity within my internal team for roles and even allocations of interviews for internal candidates" and the discontent it bred across her team. Another, working from home regularly, said she felt it damaged her promotion chances because others were simply more visible.

None of this requires a villain. It requires a rule. Institutions that move people internally tend to do four things: they commit to backfilling a secondment for its full term, so the releasing manager isn't punished; they count internal placements in managerial objectives, so development is part of the job; they require a documented operational reason for refusing a move, rather than allowing an indefinite informal veto; and they set a minimum period in role — commonly two years — that the current manager can waive but not simply invoke.

There is a recruitment argument too. The employer brand candidates actually read is what staff say about their own prospects, which is why employer branding in higher education starts with the internal experience rather than the careers page. CUPA-HR's modelling found that employees who feel supported by their supervisor are significantly less likely to look elsewhere. Support, in this context, includes letting them go somewhere else for a year and welcoming them back.

When the internal pool genuinely runs out

Internal mobility has limits, and pretending otherwise discredits it. A small institution cannot staff a chair in a discipline it has never taught from its own ranks. A new research facility needs technicians who have run that specific instrument. A clinical programme needs registered practitioners. A registry team migrating to a new student system needs people who have done that migration before, and no amount of job shadowing will substitute for the experience.

The two channels should be designed to work together. Fill what can be filled from inside, publish the data on how much you filled, and go outside for the rest — with a clear specification of what the external hire brings that the internal pool could not, and an induction that treats the newcomer as someone who might one day move internally themselves. The worst outcome is a specialist hired externally into a team with no route out of it, which is how institutions end up re-advertising the same post in three years.

This is where AcademicJobs.com complements an internal mobility programme rather than competing with it. For the roles that cannot be filled from inside, it gives universities a way to reach academic and professional specialists by discipline quickly, with fixed posting plans rather than per-click costs that strain a departmental budget, and an option to actively source candidates through public research profiles rather than waiting for applications. The sequencing matters: internal first, external when the pool is genuinely exhausted, and a written reason in the file either way.

grayscale photo of person walking on hallway

Photo by Jumi Park on Unsplash

An internal mobility checklist for the next academic year

Most of this costs nothing beyond a decision. None of it requires a new platform.

  • Publish last year's internal fill rate. The share of vacancies filled by someone already employed, broken down by department, reported to the executive annually. A number nobody collects is a number nobody improves.
  • Post every vacancy internally first. A fixed window of seven to ten days on the system staff already use. If a search is external-only, say why in the posting.
  • Extend eligibility to fixed-term and casual staff. Set a service floor of six months rather than the common rule that excludes contract staff until weeks before their contract ends.
  • Write the person specification around the work. Where a specific qualification or job title is screening candidates, check whether the law or the job requires it, or whether it is habit.
  • Fund backfill. Cost a secondment's replacement in the vacancy budget, so releasing a staff member doesn't leave the manager short.
  • Put internal placement in managerial objectives. Recognise departments that develop and release people, not only those that keep them.
  • Set a minimum period in role with a waiver route. Two years is the common benchmark; the waiver belongs to the manager, and the refusal needs a documented operational reason.
  • Build the ladder before promoting the scheme. Job families, levels, published ranges and a route for research-only staff.
  • Offer placements at every career stage. Long-serving professional staff and staff in their fifties are the group most often overlooked by programmes designed for early-career talent, and they are also the institutional memory you are about to lose.
  • Track what happens to movers. Twelve-month retention and performance outcomes for internal movers against external hires for comparable roles.
  • Keep a warm external channel for specialist roles. With a named reason, on file, for each search that goes to market.

What to count before you promise anything

If a leadership team takes one thing from this, it should be a measurement decision rather than a pledge. Four numbers, reported by department, would tell an institution more about its mobility than any strategy document: internal fill rate; median days from an internal application to a start date, compared with the external route; the share of fixed-term and casual staff who were eligible to apply for internal opportunities, not merely aware of them; and twelve-month retention and performance among people who moved sideways or up.

The professional staff member at the top of this piece wanted a conversation, not a rescue. Her manager's answer — that she was best placed where she was — was probably meant kindly, and that is what makes it a structural problem rather than a bad one. Structures hold people in place politely and by default. Counting them on purpose is the whole intervention: one published number, one vacancy posted internally first, one secondment released and backfilled. Then the next.

Universities that get this right will hire fewer people from outside, and hire better when they do. AcademicJobs.com exists for that second moment — the specialist search that no internal pool can satisfy — and its higher education jobs board is built for the departments that would rather fill the role from inside and need the outside option on the days it fails.

If your institution is ready to move, start with the roles you already know you can't fill internally. AcademicJobs.com can put them in front of specialists in the discipline while your internal process runs. The checklist above is the part only you can do.

  • internal mobility
  • higher education
  • career development
  • staff retention
  • secondments
Porträt von Prof. Evelyn Thorpe
Über den Autor

Prof. Evelyn ThorpeAutor ansehen

Academic Jobs In House Author

Prof. Evelyn Thorpe is a Contributing Writer at AcademicJobs, with a focus on environmental science and sustainability in higher education. As a Professor of Environmental Studies at the University of Sydney with over 2…

Diskussionen

Sort von:

Seien Sie der Erste, der diesen Artikel kommentiert!

Du bist

Sie werden gebeten, sich anzumelden, bevor Ihr Kommentar veröffentlicht wird.

Frequently Asked Questions

🔄What does internal mobility mean in higher education?

Internal mobility is the movement of people already employed by an institution into a different role, level, team or project without leaving the organisation. In universities it covers promotions, lateral transfers between departments, secondments of three to twelve months, job swaps, acting appointments and project placements. It is distinct from academic mobility, which usually means students or staff moving between institutions or countries.

📊How common are internal mobility programmes at universities?

Rarer than the rhetoric suggests. LinkedIn's 2025 Workplace Learning Report found that only 44% of organisations have an internal mobility programme, and that roughly one in five employees feel confident they could make an internal move where they work. In higher education, many institutions have secondment policies on the books rather than programmes, and those policies often exclude fixed-term and casual staff.

⚖️Why are fixed-term researchers so often excluded from secondments?

Mostly because secondment clauses were written for continuing staff and inherited the assumption that contract staff have no substantive post to return to. La Trobe University's procedure, for example, rules out casual and fixed-term staff; the University of Adelaide's register excludes casual and academic staff. The effect is to deny development to the group with the least security — a serious problem when 29% of UK academic staff are on fixed-term contracts and research-only roles are far more precarious still.

⏱️Do internal moves actually fill vacancies faster?

Usually, because the candidate already knows the institution, the systems and often the students. An internal move skips advertising cycles, relocation, visa processing and much of the induction burden. The gains are largest in professional and technical roles, where external searches can run for months. The advantage only materialises, though, if the internal route has a defined timeline; an internal process that drifts for eight weeks gives back most of what it saves.

🗂️What is a job architecture and why does it matter for mobility?

A job architecture groups similar roles into job families and levels, with published pay ranges and titles, so staff can see the rung above their own. Kansas State University built one covering staff roles, mapped to 37 comparator institutions; West Virginia University did it in six documented phases. Without it, progression depends on who is willing to reclassify a post, which is where favouritism and inconsistency creep in.

🤝How do you persuade managers to release good staff?

Pay the manager, not just the mover. Commit to backfilling the post for the full term of a secondment, count internal placements in managerial objectives and recognition, require a documented operational reason for refusing a move, and set a minimum period in role that the manager can waive rather than veto. The resistance is rational; the incentives need to be too.

📝What should a secondment policy contain?

Clear eligibility, including fixed-term and casual staff; a standard length, commonly three to twelve months with one extension; a right of return to the substantive post; a backfill rule; notice periods; and an approval route with named decision-makers. Victoria University's procedure is a reasonable model: it allows fixed-term and continuing staff, sets a twelve-month default with a two-year maximum in exceptional cases, and specifies negotiation for extensions and early returns.

🌍How does AcademicJobs.com complement an internal mobility programme?

It covers the roles internal pools cannot fill: a chair in a new discipline, clinical academics, technicians for unfamiliar equipment, specialists for a system migration. AcademicJobs.com lists academic and professional roles across disciplines, lets institutions post on fixed-cost plans rather than per-click pricing, and can source candidates through public research profiles when a search needs to be proactive. The sequence matters: internal first, external when the pool is genuinely empty.

📈Which metrics should we report on internal mobility?

Four will do more than a dashboard: the internal fill rate by department; median days from internal application to start date against the external route; the share of fixed-term and casual staff eligible to apply, not merely aware of opportunities; and twelve-month retention and performance for people who moved. Publish them annually, to the executive and to staff.

🎓How does internal mobility help early-career researchers?

It gives them options that don't require leaving. A postdoc who spends six months in a partnerships or research development team, or who moves into a teaching-focused contract with a defined route back, is retained by structure rather than goodwill. The Researcher Development Concordat sets ten days a year for professional development; institutions that don't track how researchers use those days can't tell whether mobility is happening or merely available.

⚙️Can internal mobility improve equity and representation?

It can widen access to progression, but only if the process is visible. When internal roles are filled through informal networks, the staff who are already visible benefit most, and those working remotely, part-time or from under-represented groups lose out. Publishing internal vacancies for a fixed window and using a scoring rubric agreed in advance are modest controls that make a measurable difference.

🚀What's the first step if there's no budget for a mobility programme?

Post every vacancy internally for a fixed window before it goes external, and start counting your internal fill rate. Both are policy decisions rather than spending commitments. The expensive parts — job architecture, backfill, benchmarking against comparator institutions — can follow once you can show how many staff are currently choosing to leave instead of moving.