The Incident Unfolds at UC Graduation

On April 15, 2026, during a University of Canterbury graduation ceremony at Wolfbrook Arena in Christchurch, a moment of celebration turned contentious for one graduate. Davien Gray, a 24-year-old who had just earned a Bachelor of Arts degree majoring in sociology and media and communications, along with a Senior Scholarship for academic excellence, was approached by a senior security staff member just before crossing the stage to receive their degree. Gray was instructed to remove their keffiyeh—a traditional Middle Eastern checkered cotton scarf—before entering the arena. Despite offering to tuck it under their academic regalia, the scarf was confiscated, and Gray was told it would be available at the information desk afterward.

Gray, who had traveled from overseas with family in attendance, described the interaction as hostile. The security staff did not inquire about the scarf's significance or accept the compromise, leaving Gray feeling shocked, demeaned, and unable to refuse without risking missing their moment on stage. Ultimately, Gray complied, participated in the ceremony, and retrieved the item later.

Davien Gray's Perspective and Complaint

For Gray, the keffiyeh held deep personal meaning. Not Palestinian themselves, Gray wore it to honor Palestinian students whose universities have been impacted by bombings amid the ongoing Israel-Palestine conflict. It was not intended as a protest or disruption but as a quiet act of solidarity during a milestone event. 'It wasn’t a protest or in any way a disruption to my graduating cohort,' Gray told reporters. The experience left them feeling belittled, especially after going out of their way to comply with guidelines by positioning the scarf under the gown.

Following the ceremony, Gray lodged a formal complaint through UC's student complaints procedure. The university confirmed it is investigating the matter, with Gray connected to the University of Canterbury Students’ Association for support. Gray also highlighted prior complaints about UC security staff, including alleged assaults during pro-Palestine protests on campus.

UC's Graduation Attire Policy Explained

The University of Canterbury maintains strict guidelines for graduation attire to ensure uniformity and formality during ceremonies. Full academic regalia—gown, hood, and trencher—is mandatory for participants crossing the stage. Hoods are color-coded by faculty, such as Baby Pink for Arts, with specific shapes and materials prescribed in the Academic Dress and Specification Regulations.

Cultural expression is explicitly welcomed, but within limits. Students may wear a cultural or heirloom brooch as the only accessory on regalia. 'Garments of honour from your own tradition such as a kākahu/korowai or ta’ovala' are permitted, typically worn under the hood or stole. Examples given are Māori cloaks or Pacific ta’ovala, emphasizing items tied to one's heritage. The policy does not explicitly mention keffiyehs, leading to debate over whether it qualifies as a 'garment of honour from your own tradition.'

UC's graduation guide stresses practical, comfortable shoes and no other accessories like framed photos. This framework aims to balance tradition with inclusivity, but the Gray incident has spotlighted gray areas in interpretation.

University Response and Ongoing Investigation

UC acknowledged the complaint promptly, stating it 'will continue to progress the matter carefully and in line with these processes.' A spokesperson emphasized, 'Cultural garments of honour are welcomed to be worn within the guidance provided in advance to all students attending graduation celebrations.' The university applies regulations consistently across events and has offered support to both Gray and the security staff involved.

Complaints are handled via the UC Concerns portal, with referrals to the Students’ Association. No timeline for resolution has been given, and an officer has not yet been assigned. Deputy Vice-Chancellor Catherine Moran met with concerned parties, including Green Party MP Kahurangi Carter, who raised freedom of expression issues.

Cultural and Symbolic Role of the Keffiyeh

🌍 The keffiyeh, known as a shemagh or hatta in some contexts, originated as practical headwear for Bedouin Arabs to protect against sun and sand. Its black-and-white pattern, popularized by Yasser Arafat, has evolved into a global symbol of Palestinian identity and resistance. In New Zealand, it appears at pro-Palestine rallies and among supporters expressing solidarity.

While not exclusively Palestinian, it carries political connotations amid the Israel-Gaza conflict. Gray's intent was remembrance, not activism, but critics question if such symbols belong in formal academic settings focused on achievement. Supporters argue it represents personal heritage in a diverse society, akin to Māori korowai.

Campus Climate and Related Security Incidents

The keffiyeh episode occurs amid heightened tensions at UC. Pro-Palestine groups like Students for Justice in Palestine Canterbury have organized protests, encampments, and vigils. Security has faced complaints, including poster removals and alleged rough handling during a May 2025 demonstration where police intervened after protesters entered a staff area.

• In April 2026, security tore down pro-Palestine artwork, sparking freedom of expression concerns.
• Social media posts from activist groups label UC security actions as Islamophobic or racist.
• UC revised its freedom of expression statement per Education and Training Act amendments, affirming debate but prohibiting disruption.

These events reflect global campus divides over the Middle East conflict, with NZ universities navigating protests while maintaining order.

Dress Codes in Other New Zealand Universities

UC's policy aligns with peers, prioritizing academic regalia while allowing cultural items.

• University of Auckland: Garments like sari, korowai, or ta’ovala welcomed under hood.
• Victoria University of Wellington: Māori kākahu or Pacific ta’ovala under hood/stole; brooches allowed.
• University of Otago: Strict regalia, no mixing degrees; cultural additions not detailed but formal attire expected.
• AUT: Specific colors/styles by subject; formal over regalia.

All emphasize uniformity for ceremony dignity, with cultural accommodations for heritage items. No explicit bans on keffiyehs, but political symbols may fall outside 'honour' categories.

Stakeholder Perspectives and Public Backlash

Reactions vary. Pro-Palestine Instagram posts from UCSJP call it 'overtly racist' and Islamophobic. Green MP Carter demanded clarity on expression rights. Some defend UC, arguing graduations require neutrality to honor all graduates without political statements.

Experts note tension between uniformity and diversity. NZ Universities vice-chancellor Dawn Freshwater stresses policies support inclusion. Petitions circulate online, but no widespread protests reported.

For deeper insight, see the NZ Herald report on Gray's account.

Implications for Free Speech and Inclusion

This case highlights challenges in balancing free expression, cultural diversity, and ceremonial decorum. NZ's Education and Training Act mandates universities protect speech, but allows limits on disruption. Is a keffiyeh speech or attire? Does 'own tradition' exclude solidarity symbols?

Broader impacts: Could deter international students? Affect campus climate amid Gaza debates? UC's investigation may set precedent for interpreting policies.

Similar Controversies in Higher Education

Not isolated. In Australia, a Year 12 student sued over keffiyeh ban at formal, settling after policy clarification. US/UK graduations saw keffiyehs, Palestinian flags disrupting ceremonies. NZ/Aus unis generally permit cultural items but scrutinize political ones.

Explore UC's full Academic Dress Regulations.

Photo by Raka Rahmadani on Unsplash

Looking Ahead: Lessons for NZ Universities

UC's outcome could influence peers. Clearer guidelines on solidarity symbols? Training for staff? Enhanced dialogue on expression?

For those in higher ed, this underscores navigating diversity amid global tensions. Check opportunities at NZ university jobs.

UC remains committed to investigation, promising transparency. As NZ's second-largest university (20,000+ students), its handling matters for inclusion standards.