Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

theosis: 5 research paper to explain

12 min read0 views

At a glance

Five research papers on theosis, from Calvin to Chinese house churches, show a doctrine spreading fast across traditions while scholars still argue over what the word means.

Close-up of a page from a book with text
Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

Five research papers. No two of them mean quite the same thing by the word. That is the story.

The familiar version of this subject runs like this: theosis is an ancient Greek doctrine of becoming God, kept alive by Orthodox monks, now enjoying a Western revival. It's a tidy story, and it flatters everyone involved. The revival part is real. One recent paper counts at least fifteen books or edited collections on deification in two decades, running from Norman Russell's history to Khaled Anatolios's account of salvation through the cross. What that count doesn't show is that the boom has produced a fight about definitions, and the fight is where the interesting work is happening.

So: five papers, spread from a 2002 reading of John Calvin to a 2025 reading of a Chinese church movement, with the disagreements left in instead of smoothed over.

The word, before the argument

Theosis is Greek for making divine. Latin gives deificatio, English gives deification, and some writers prefer divinization. The working one-liner that most scholars accept: to become, by grace, what God is by nature.

Its scriptural anchor is a single clause in the second letter of Peter, where believers are called partakers of the divine nature. The Gospel of John supplies the vine-and-branches image of abiding; the first letter of John supplies the promise that we shall be like him. Irenaeus wrote that the Word became what we are in order to make us what he is. Athanasius put it more bluntly: God became man in order that man might become God. John of Damascus reached for iron in a fire, which becomes fire not by its own nature but by being united with flame, and argued that the saints are deified the same way, by grace rather than by constitution.

Two things about the doctrine get lost in popular retellings. It was never reserved for an elite. As classically stated, deification is the central dynamic of salvation for every person, and it isn't confined to the soul. The body is deified too, which is the theology standing behind the veneration of relics. The second is the mechanism: the distinction between God's essence and God's energies. The essence stays unapproachable; what human beings are joined to is God's activity, his self-communication. Gregory Palamas draws that line most sharply, though it runs back through the Cappadocians and the Alexandrians before him.

For a baseline, the book to own is Norman Russell's The Doctrine of Deification in the Greek Patristic Tradition, published by Oxford University Press in 2004. It was the first treatment of the subject in over sixty years when it appeared, tracing deification from a second-century metaphor to a doctrine woven into Byzantine spiritual life, with appendices on the Syriac and Latin traditions and on the Greek vocabulary. Andrew Louth called it a masterpiece in the Times Higher Education Supplement; Anthony Meredith, reviewing it in the Journal of Theological Studies, said its scope and precision were beyond praise. It's a monograph, not one of the five below, but nearly all of them stand on it.

One: deification with a living room in it

Michael Reardon and Brian Siu Kit Chiu open their 2025 paper in Religions with an inventory of the field and name two problems that matter. The first is definitional: the doctrine's content shifts across thinkers, centuries and geographies, and Russell himself has said it now needs a clear working definition because it has entered both mainstream theological traditions and popular spirituality. The second is that the literature is heavy on texts and light on practice. Centuries of commentary on what deification is. Very little on what a Christian does on a Tuesday.

Their case study is a Chinese Protestant movement, and the biography is worth spelling out. Witness Lee was born in northern China in 1905 and raised by a mother who was a third-generation Southern Baptist. He converted at nineteen at a gospel meeting led by the evangelist Peace Wang, spent his early adult years among the Brethren assemblies, and moved to Shanghai in 1934 to work with Watchman Nee, editing Nee's periodical The Christian for six years. By 1949 the two had established more than 400 congregations across 30 provinces. Nee was imprisoned by the new Communist government; Lee left for Taiwan, then moved to California in 1962, founded Living Stream Ministry, and died in 1997 at ninety-one.

The reach is the part that should stop a Western reader. An estimated 1.5 to 2 million Christians meet in churches that Nee and Lee's ministry established, and tens of millions in underground Chinese churches have been shaped by their writings. Lee's collected works run to 139 volumes, more than 78,000 pages.

What Reardon and Chiu pull out of that corpus is a practical account they call the God-man living. On Lee's reading, deification isn't the external imitation of Christ's virtues that imitatio Christi traditions describe. It is the reproduction of Christ's life inside a believer, growing the way a life grows. Lee treats imitation by self-effort as a mistake, and he says so: believers should not try to copy Christ out of their natural life, but learn him according to the reality in Jesus. He also reminds his readers of their status as God-men, because, in his words, that status will affect the way they live. The reframing is why the paper earns its place. It moves a doctrine usually argued in the register of essence and energies into the register of habit, conduct, and what a person does when nobody is watching. The paper is open access in Religions.

Two: the biology problem

Mikael Leidenhag's 2021 article in the Toronto Journal of Theology starts from a claim that sounds strange to anyone who files theosis under devotion: the doctrine entails a robustly teleological conception of humanity. Purpose, in other words, built into the structure of the creature rather than bolted on.

His test case is Maximus the Confessor and the distinction, drawn in Ambiguum 7, between logos and tropos. A logos is the principle that defines a nature; a tropos is the way a particular being actually lives that nature out. Deification, on this reading, is tropos catching up with logos, the mode of existence finally matching the purpose built into it. That is how Maximus explains damage without explaining away design. The logoi stay intact even when human beings have turned their attention to the sensory world and live at odds with what they are, which is why the soul can be described as fragmented, its parts confused, its wholeness lost.

Then the payoff, aimed at a live quarrel: the tension between Orthodox theology and evolutionary biology. Leidenhag works through non-reductionist accounts of evolution and the shift in biological research from mechanism to organism, and concludes that Eastern Orthodoxy brings a well-needed realism about the epistemic limits of the natural sciences. Whether or not you buy the conclusion, notice what the paper isn't doing. It isn't defending theosis against science. It's using the doctrine to say something about what science can and cannot settle. A version is free in the St Andrews repository; the work was supported by the Science and Orthodoxy around the World project.

a close up of a book with writing on it

Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

Three: Maximus against the transhumanists

Eugenia Torrance's 2019 article in Studies in Christian Ethics puts Maximus in the same room as Nick Bostrom and John Harris, and the pairing is less contrived than it looks. Both the patristic doctrine and the transhumanist programme treat death as the enemy and point towards transcendence of the conditions we were born into.

Where they part is human nature. Torrance argues that Maximus holds a more dynamic, open-ended view of that nature than late antiquity is usually credited with, and yet insists it persists, intact, into the eschaton. Her reasons deserve an airing the next time a longevity pitch uses the word transcendence. Theosis depends on sharing a human nature with Christ, so a humanity left behind is a humanity that cannot be deified. Bodies, she argues, are the locus of our shared existence with the material world, which is what makes the vocation of mediator in creation something other than a metaphor. Then there is the claim that will get a philosopher of technology shifting in his seat: corruption has a providential use. The argument is in Studies in Christian Ethics, and it reads less like a rejection of medicine than a warning about rhetoric that treats the body as an obstacle to be engineered away.

Four: Calvin, of all people

Rewind to 2002. Carl Mosser, then at St Mary's College in St Andrews, published an article in the Scottish Journal of Theology with a title calculated to irritate: The greatest possible blessing: Calvin and deification. The assumption under attack was that deification belongs to the Greek East and to nobody in the post-patristic West. Recent scholarship had already located it in Augustine, Aquinas, Luther, early Anglicanism, early Methodism and Jonathan Edwards. Mosser added the reformer of Geneva.

The case is deliberately measured, and the measure is part of the point. Deification is not a prominent theme in Calvin in its own right, and some of the bolder patristic vocabulary never appears. But the concept and the imagery keep surfacing while Calvin explicates other doctrines, and for him deification is the eschatological goal, the blessing greater than which nothing can be imagined. The claim has been contested ever since, in a literature of its own. It still reset the terms: deification stopped being a marker of Eastern identity and became a question about what union with Christ means in any tradition that takes the phrase seriously. The article is on Cambridge Core.

Five: the sceptic who did the reading

Michael Habets's 2024 article in the Journal of Reformed Theology is the one to read if the Mosser line feels too generous. Herman Bavinck, the Dutch Reformed dogmatician, is usually filed as a rejectionist on deification. Some recent work argues he actually supported a version of it. Habets disagrees with the rehabilitation and disagrees with Bavinck, arguing that Bavinck misunderstood the nature of deification and rejected it on false grounds. He then brings Bavinck into dialogue with Thomas F. Torrance's endorsement of theosis to show why the two never meet, even once the mysticism Bavinck rightly opposed is removed from the picture.

A paper like this does something the cheerleading literature can't. It demonstrates that the definition decides the verdict. Use a thin account of deification and half the Western tradition turns out to qualify. Use a thick one and a serious Reformed theologian can reject the doctrine while rejecting something the Greek Fathers would also have rejected. Habets's argument is published by Brill.

Here's the catch

Gösta Hallonsten made the objection years ago and nobody has answered it: scholars have been conflating the doctrine of theosis with themes related to theosis. The doctrine, as he described it, is a package. A view of creation and of human beings. A soteriology, including a position on what the Incarnation is for. An account of the Christian life as sanctification bound to church and sacraments. A final goal of union with God. Take a piece of that and call it theosis and you have a mood, not a doctrine.

Two of the papers above concede as much. Reardon and Chiu note that Russell, after decades tracing the concept, says it now requires a clear working definition precisely because it has crossed into mainstream theological traditions and popular spirituality. That last clause matters. Popular spirituality is where a word goes to become a brand.

So the boom is real and partly an artefact of loose usage. Fifteen books in twenty years is a lot of pages. It is not fifteen books making the same claim. The historical scholarship, with Russell at the head of it, is durable. The wider assertion, that a doctrine once at home in the Greek East now organises Protestant soteriology, Chinese church practice and arguments about biotechnology, is a hypothesis under construction. Some of its load-bearing beams are being tested by people who want it to hold, which is the right way round.

a close up of an open book with writing on it

Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

Where the hype outruns the evidence

Sort the popular claims by what the five papers actually support.

The claimWhat the research supports
Theosis is an Eastern Orthodox doctrine.Its formative influence is greatest in the Greek East, and Russell's history is a Greek patristic one. But Mosser finds the concept operating in Calvin, Habets fights over whether Bavinck rejected the real thing, and Reardon and Chiu locate a practical version in a Chinese Protestant movement with millions of adherents.
It's mystical, monastic, for specialists.As classically stated it is the central dynamic of salvation for every person, body included. Lee's version is domestic by design: what a believer does in an ordinary day, not what an ascetic achieves on a pillar.
It rivals Western accounts of salvation.Torrance uses it to argue against transhumanism. Leidenhag uses it to argue about biological teleology. Neither is arguing with Geneva.
The definition is settled.It isn't. The field's own practitioners say so in print, in 2024 and again in 2025.

Grade the historical recovery: high. Grade the claim that theosis now functions as shared ecumenical vocabulary: incomplete, and in places circular. Grade the practical literature: early, and honest about being early. Reardon and Chiu end by calling for work that puts Lee's God-man living alongside patristic accounts of practical theosis, Protestant participation theology and Pentecostal treatments of divine empowerment. That's a research agenda, not a result.

The least fashionable claim in all five papers belongs to Torrance, and it's the one worth carrying out of the room. She argues that corruption has a providential use, binding us together with our neighbours and cultivating virtue as we strain for what she calls the incorruptible and supernatural gift of theosis. No publisher would put that on a cover. It also happens to be the sentence that explains why a doctrine this old keeps attracting people who have never used the word.

  • theology-research
  • theology-research
  • theosis
  • theosis
  • deification
Portrait of Dr. Oliver Fenton
About the author

Dr. Oliver FentonView author

Academic Jobs In House Author

Dr. Oliver Fenton is a Contributing Writer at AcademicJobs, specializing in research publication trends and scientific communication. With a PhD in Science Communication from Imperial College London, he has over 15 year…

Discussion

Sort by:

Be the first to comment on this article!

You

You’ll be asked to sign in before your comment is posted.

Browse by Faculty

Browse by Subject

Frequently Asked Questions

📖What is theosis in simple terms?

Theosis is the Greek term usually translated as deification or divinization. In its classic one-line form, it means becoming, by grace, what God is by nature. It describes salvation as participation in the divine life rather than only as forgiveness or a legal verdict, and it is grounded in passages such as 2 Peter 1:4, where believers are called partakers of the divine nature.

🕊️Is theosis the same as deification?

Yes, for practical purposes. Theosis is the Greek word; deificatio is the Latin equivalent, and English writers use deification or divinization. Some scholars prefer divinization because deification can suggest a human being turned into a second god, which the doctrine denies. The distinction the tradition insists on is that human beings are deified by grace and participation, never by nature.

📚Which five research papers does this article discuss?

Michael Reardon and Brian Siu Kit Chiu on Witness Lee and the God-man living, published in Religions in 2025; Mikael Leidenhag on theosis and organismic teleology in the Toronto Journal of Theology in 2021; Eugenia Torrance on Maximus the Confessor and transhumanism in Studies in Christian Ethics in 2019; Carl Mosser on Calvin and deification in the Scottish Journal of Theology in 2002; and Michael Habets on Herman Bavinck's rejection of theosis in the Journal of Reformed Theology in 2024.

⚖️Why do scholars disagree about the definition of theosis?

The doctrine's content shifts across thinkers, centuries and regions, and it has now entered both mainstream theological traditions and popular spirituality. Theologian Gösta Hallonsten warned that researchers were conflating the doctrine of theosis with themes related to theosis. Norman Russell, whose history of the concept is the standard reference, has said a clear working definition is needed precisely because the term has spread so widely.

✝️Did John Calvin teach deification?

Carl Mosser argued in 2002 that the concept is present in Calvin's theology, though not as a prominent theme in its own right and without the bolder patristic vocabulary. On Mosser's reading, deification is for Calvin the eschatological goal, the blessing greater than which nothing can be imagined. The claim has been disputed since, and the debate continues in journals such as the Scottish Journal of Theology.

🌍What is the God-man living in Witness Lee's theology?

It is the practical account of deification that Reardon and Chiu draw from the writings of Witness Lee, the Chinese church leader who lived from 1905 to 1997. Rather than external imitation of Christ's virtues, Lee describes deification as the progressive reproduction of Christ's life within a believer, expressed in ordinary daily conduct. He treats imitation by sheer self-effort as a mistake and points instead to learning Christ according to the reality in Jesus.

🔬How does theosis relate to transhumanism?

Both treat death as an enemy and aim at transcendence of present human limits, which is why Eugenia Torrance compares Maximus the Confessor with Nick Bostrom and John Harris. She argues that Maximus holds a strikingly dynamic view of human nature, yet insists that nature persists intact into the eschaton. Theosis depends on sharing a human nature with Christ, so any programme that abandons human nature undercuts the doctrine at its root.

🏛️What is the essence and energies distinction?

It is the theological distinction that explains how human beings can be united to God without becoming God by nature. God's essence remains unapproachable; what creatures participate in is God's activity or self-communication, called the divine energies. The distinction appears in the Alexandrian and Cappadocian Fathers and is drawn most sharply by Gregory Palamas, and it is what keeps deification from collapsing divine transcendence.

🔎Who is Norman Russell and why does his book matter?

Norman Russell is a scholar of patristic theology whose 2004 monograph The Doctrine of Deification in the Greek Patristic Tradition, published by Oxford University Press, was the first full treatment of the subject in over sixty years. It traces the idea from a second-century metaphor to a doctrine at the centre of Byzantine spiritual life, and it includes appendices on the Syriac and Latin traditions and on the Greek vocabulary of deification.

💬Is theosis only for monks and clergy?

No. As classically stated, deification is the central dynamic of salvation for every person rather than an exceptional state reserved for a few. It also concerns the body, not the soul alone, and in the Eastern tradition that is one reason the bodies of saints are venerated. The practical versions of the doctrine, such as the God-man living described by Reardon and Chiu, are explicitly aimed at ordinary believers.

🧠What does Maximus the Confessor's logos and tropos distinction mean?

A logos is the principle defining a particular nature; a tropos is the mode in which a specific being actually lives that nature out. Mikael Leidenhag argues that for Maximus deification consists in the tropos coming into alignment with the logos, so that the way a person lives finally matches the purpose built into the creature. The logoi remain intact even when human beings live at odds with them.

📝Does theosis conflict with evolutionary biology?

Leidenhag argues that the tension can be eased rather than sharpened. He explores non-reductionist accounts of evolution and the shift in biological research from mechanism to organism, and concludes that Eastern Orthodoxy brings a needed realism about the epistemic limits of the natural sciences. The claim is not that biology proves the doctrine, but that a teleological reading of nature is not automatically ruled out by the science.