A new peer-reviewed study examines whether Australian local governments are moving beyond incremental adjustments to pursue deeper systems change in sustainability governance. Titled "Are local governments pursuing deeper systems change through sustainability governance? Analysis of seven Australian case studies," the research was authored by Eleanor Robson and published in Geoforum.
The open-access article is available at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0016718526001193. Robson, who completed related doctoral work at Western Sydney University on planetary health and sustainability governance in the Blue Mountains, now serves as Policy Director for Environment, Climate and Waste at the Australian Local Government Association.
Study methodology and scope
Robson conducted a qualitative analysis drawing on interviews with representatives from seven Australian local governments and three local government associations. Data collection focused on practices in 2022, allowing the researcher to assess contemporary approaches amid evolving national and state-level sustainability frameworks. The study applied Scoones et al.'s 2020 framework on transformations to categorize governance efforts along a spectrum from incremental reforms to more systemic shifts.
Local governments in Australia hold significant responsibilities for land-use planning, waste management, environmental protection, and community services, positioning them as key actors in sustainability transitions. The seven case studies represented a mix of urban, regional, and coastal councils, providing a broad view of practices across different contexts and scales.
Key findings on governance approaches
The analysis revealed that proactive local governments predominantly employ reforming and systemic approaches. These councils leverage statutory responsibilities, such as planning powers and environmental regulations, to raise ambition levels beyond minimum compliance requirements. Rather than treating sustainability as a standalone add-on, leading examples integrate it across multiple policy domains including climate adaptation, biodiversity protection, and circular economy initiatives.
In contrast, some councils remained more focused on narrower, project-based actions with limited evidence of deeper structural change. The study highlights how statutory mandates can serve as enabling tools when combined with internal leadership, cross-departmental coordination, and engagement with state and federal programs.
Photo by Joshua Leong on Unsplash
Context of Australian local government sustainability efforts
Australia's 537 local governments operate under state and territory legislation, with varying degrees of autonomy in environmental and planning matters. National strategies such as the Net Zero by 2050 target and state-level climate acts create an overarching policy environment that influences local action. The research situates its case studies within this multi-level governance landscape, noting both opportunities for alignment and barriers arising from inconsistent funding, regulatory fragmentation, and capacity constraints.
Related work by Robson on the City of Blue Mountains demonstrates how one council has experimented with integrative approaches that connect planetary health principles to everyday governance decisions. This provides a concrete illustration of the broader patterns identified across the seven cases.
Implications for policy and practice
The findings suggest that deeper systems change is possible when local governments actively use their existing legal powers in combination with collaborative networks and long-term strategic planning. Associations play a supporting role by sharing knowledge and advocating for enabling policy environments at higher levels of government.
For practitioners, the study underscores the value of moving from siloed environmental projects toward whole-of-council strategies that address interconnected social, economic, and ecological challenges. It also points to the importance of monitoring and evaluation frameworks that can track progress toward transformative outcomes rather than solely short-term outputs.
Connections to academic research and higher education
Robson's work contributes to ongoing scholarly conversations in environmental governance, urban studies, and sustainability transitions. Universities across Australia, including Western Sydney University, continue to produce research that informs local government practice through partnerships, student projects, and policy advice. The publication offers a timely resource for academics examining multi-level governance and the conditions under which incremental actions scale into systemic change.
Researchers in related fields may find the case-study approach and analytical framework useful for comparative studies in other jurisdictions facing similar challenges of climate change, biodiversity loss, and resource management.
Photo by Nathan Hurst on Unsplash
Challenges identified and pathways forward
The study acknowledges persistent barriers, including limited financial resources, competing priorities, and the need for stronger vertical integration with state and federal policies. It also notes that genuine systems change often requires cultural shifts within organizations alongside technical and regulatory adjustments.
Looking ahead, the research points to opportunities for enhanced peer learning among councils, greater use of data-driven decision-making, and alignment with emerging national frameworks on climate and environment. Continued experimentation by leading councils could generate transferable lessons for the sector as a whole.
Broader relevance in 2026
As Australia advances its climate and sustainability agenda, local governments remain critical implementation partners. The publication provides evidence-based insights at a moment when many councils are updating their environmental strategies and community plans. It offers a balanced assessment that recognizes both progress and the distance still to travel toward transformative governance.
Readers interested in the full analysis can access the article directly through the ScienceDirect link provided above.