Italy's Defense Minister Advocates for Stronger European Self-Reliance
Italian Defense Minister Guido Crosetto has called for European nations to develop a new joint defense system, emphasizing the need for greater self-reliance amid shifting global security dynamics. In a recent interview, Crosetto highlighted that European countries must take more responsibility for their own security rather than depending heavily on external partners.
Background on European Defense Cooperation
European defense has long been intertwined with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, but recent years have seen increased discussions about supplementary structures within the European Union framework. Initiatives such as the Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO) and the European Defence Fund have aimed to enhance collaboration among member states on capability development and joint procurement. These efforts build on decades of incremental progress toward greater strategic autonomy.
The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has accelerated these conversations, prompting EU leaders to reassess reliance on traditional alliances. Proposals for enhanced European defense structures have gained traction as countries seek to address capability gaps and ensure rapid response capabilities.
Details of the Italian Proposal
Crosetto's remarks point toward forging a new intergovernmental framework that would allow for more integrated military planning and resource sharing among willing European partners. This would complement existing NATO commitments while addressing specific regional needs, including Mediterranean security concerns important to Italy.
The proposal aligns with broader EU discussions led by figures such as Defense Commissioner Andrius Kubilius, who has advocated for a new treaty to establish a European Defence Union. Such a structure could involve the United Kingdom, Norway, and potentially Ukraine, going beyond current treaty limitations.
Italy's Strategic Position and Recent Actions
Under Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, Italy has balanced NATO obligations with efforts to bolster domestic and European defense industries. The government previously applied for significant funding under the EU's Security Action for Europe (SAFE) program, which provides loans to accelerate defense investments. Italy had been allocated up to €14.9 billion, though recent statements indicate a potential scaling back to focus on existing commitments amid energy cost pressures.
Italy maintains a defense spending trajectory toward NATO targets and has supported partnerships that include non-EU allies. This approach seeks to maintain transatlantic ties while fostering intra-European industrial cooperation.
Photo by Taisha Ellison on Unsplash
EU-Wide Context and Related Initiatives
The European Commission has advanced the Readiness 2030 plan, formerly known as ReArm Europe, aiming to mobilize substantial resources for defense infrastructure. This includes financial instruments like SAFE, adopted in 2025, to close critical capability gaps and support the European defense industry.
Other member states have engaged variably with these efforts, with some prioritizing rapid procurement and others focusing on industrial base strengthening. The emphasis remains on collective deterrence without duplicating NATO structures.
Stakeholder Perspectives and Reactions
Italian officials frame the initiative as essential for sovereignty and effective response to hybrid threats. Defense industry representatives see opportunities for joint projects that could enhance competitiveness globally.
Other European leaders have expressed cautious support, noting the importance of complementarity with NATO. Discussions continue in EU forums about the legal and operational feasibility of new treaty-based arrangements.
Potential Impacts on Regional Security
A strengthened European defense framework could improve interoperability among forces, streamline procurement, and accelerate innovation in areas such as drones, cyber defense, and missile systems. It might also provide additional support mechanisms for partners like Ukraine.
Challenges include differing national priorities, budgetary constraints, and the need to avoid fragmentation of existing alliances. Success would depend on inclusive decision-making and clear command structures.
Challenges and Considerations
Implementing a new alliance requires navigating complex political landscapes across diverse EU member states. Fiscal pressures, public opinion on defense spending, and coordination with NATO remain key hurdles.
Italy's own adjustments to SAFE participation illustrate the balancing act between ambitious goals and domestic economic realities.
Future Outlook
Discussions are expected to intensify ahead of upcoming NATO and EU summits. Progress on a new treaty or enhanced cooperation mechanisms could reshape Europe's security architecture over the coming decade.
Observers will monitor Italy's role in bridging positions between larger powers and smaller states with varying threat perceptions.
Implications for Broader Geopolitics
Enhanced European self-defense capabilities could contribute to a more multipolar security environment, influencing relations with major powers. It may also support stability in adjacent regions through improved crisis management tools.
Long-term success hinges on sustained political will and effective integration of industrial and operational elements.
