📋 Uncovering the Underpayment at University of Adelaide

The University of Adelaide, one of Australia's leading research institutions, recently made headlines by admitting to underpaying hundreds of its casual academic staff. This revelation came to light in late October 2025, highlighting a significant compliance issue spanning nearly eight years. The institution self-reported the problem after conducting enhanced internal audits, a move prompted by widespread concerns across the higher education sector regarding wage compliance.

Casual academic staff, who often serve as tutors, lecturers, or course coordinators on short-term contracts, form a vital part of university teaching workloads. In Australia, these roles are governed by enterprise agreements—collective bargaining documents that outline pay rates, loadings, and entitlements. The underpayments stemmed from failures to apply specific higher pay rates under these agreements, particularly for staff holding PhDs or taking on coordinator responsibilities.

This incident is not isolated but part of a larger pattern in Australian universities, where complex payment structures and heavy reliance on casual labor have led to systemic errors. For prospective academics eyeing opportunities in South Australia, understanding these dynamics is crucial when exploring university jobs or assessing professor salaries.

Details of the Wage Shortfalls

The total underpayment amounted to approximately $1.25 million, affecting 838 current and former casual academic staff members between March 2017 and May 2025. On average, each affected individual was short-changed by around $1,500—a figure that equates to less than 0.05% of the university's total salary payments over the period but still represents a substantial loss for those on precarious incomes.

About 60% of the impacted workers were former staff, complicating remediation efforts as some may have moved on to other institutions or careers. The specific issues involved not paying elevated rates for PhD-qualified tutors or course coordinators as mandated by the University of Adelaide Enterprise Agreement and its predecessors. For instance, a PhD student transitioning to a doctorate holder might not have received the corresponding loading—a higher hourly rate recognizing advanced qualifications.

Casual loading in Australia compensates for lack of permanent benefits like paid leave, typically at 25% above base rates. Enterprise agreements layer additional steps based on qualifications and duties, creating a matrix prone to administrative oversights when managed locally rather than centrally.

• Period covered: March 2017 to May 2025
• Total staff affected: 838 (primarily casual academics)
• Average underpayment per person: ~$1,500
• Total shortfall: $1.25 million
• Key entitlements missed: PhD loadings, course coordinator premiums

Such discrepancies underscore the importance of accurate payroll systems, especially for sessional staff whose hours fluctuate with teaching semesters.

The University's Response and Remediation Process

University of Adelaide Vice-Chancellor Peter Høj described the underpayments as a 'breakdown in systems, not a knowing action,' attributing them to the complexity of industrial instruments administered at faculty levels. In an email to staff dated September 25, 2025, he expressed deep regret, calling the matter 'unfortunate and very regrettable.' The university immediately notified the Fair Work Ombudsman and initiated a remediation program.

Remediation involves contacting all affected individuals—current staff via payroll and former ones through available records—and issuing back-payments plus interest where applicable. Ongoing audits aim to uncover any additional instances, with promises of swift correction. Enhanced processes and controls are being implemented to prevent recurrence, including better training for local administrators and centralized oversight.

Høj emphasized sector-wide simplification: 'We need as a university and as a sector to make it simpler both for those who pay and for those who work for us to know exactly what their entitlements are.' This proactive stance has been welcomed by some, though critics argue it highlights governance gaps ahead of the university's merger with the University of South Australia into the new Adelaide University on January 1, 2026.

🎯 Fair Work Ombudsman's Role in the Investigation

The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO), Australia's workplace regulator, confirmed it is investigating the self-reported underpayments. Since 2022, the FWO has targeted systemic non-compliance in universities, recovering millions in owed wages nationwide. Employers identifying issues must cooperate fully, with the FWO prioritizing education over penalties for voluntary disclosures but reserving enforcement for deliberate breaches.

As of early 2026, no public outcome has been announced for Adelaide, but precedents like the University of Wollongong's $6.6 million repayment to over 5,000 staff illustrate potential resolutions via enforceable undertakings—binding agreements for back-pay and compliance reforms. Staff suspecting shortfalls can lodge anonymous tips via the FWO hotline or website, empowering individuals in South Australia higher ed jobs.

Photo by 0xk on Unsplash

Impacts on Casual Academic Staff and the Sector

For casual academics, often early-career researchers or postgraduate students supplementing income, even modest shortfalls compound financial stress amid rising living costs. Many rely on these roles for teaching experience to secure permanent lecturer jobs, making timely payments critical.

The National Tertiary Education Union (NTEU) South Australia secretary Dr. Andrew Miller warned this could be 'the tip of the iceberg,' as audits focused narrowly on enterprise agreement compliance. Broader NTEU analysis reveals over $159 million in university wage theft since 2014, affecting nearly 100,000 staff across 33+ institutions—a stark indictment of casualization, where casuals deliver up to 50% of teaching.

Examples include University of Melbourne's $45 million to 30,000 casuals and University of Sydney's $70+ million liabilities. These erode trust, prompting calls for better governance amid mergers like Adelaide's.Read the ABC report for full context.

📊 Wage Underpayment Trends in Australian Universities

Australia's higher education sector grapples with wage underpayment due to:

• High casual workforce (45-50% of teaching staff)
• Complex enterprise agreements with qualification/role-based rates
• Decentralized payroll in large, federated structures
• Pressure from international student revenue declines post-COVID

NTEU data shows five in six public universities implicated, with totals exceeding $284 million by late 2025. Common pitfalls: unpaid preparation/marking time, misclassified overtime, and missed loadings. For job seekers, reviewing payslips against agreements is essential—check hourly rates match steps for quals like PhD (often 20-50% uplift).

Government inquiries urge standardized systems and union audits. Explore university salaries data for benchmarks.

Strategies for Prevention and Best Practices

Universities can mitigate risks by:

• Centralizing payroll with automated rate calculators
• Mandatory training on enterprise agreements
• Regular third-party audits
• Transparent payslip breakdowns
• Union-staff forums for entitlement education

Staff should retain timesheets, compare against award/agreement via FWO tools, and join NTEU for advocacy. Aspiring academics can leverage academic CV tips to negotiate clear contracts upfront.

Practical Advice for Staff and Job Seekers

If you worked casually at University of Adelaide (2017-2025), monitor emails/payroll portals for remediation notices. Uncontacted? Contact HR or FWO. For others:

1. Review payslips quarterly against FWO pay guides (external, verified active).
2. Document hours including prep/marking (often 2-3x contact time).
3. Join NTEU for free entitlements checks.
4. When applying to higher ed jobs, ask about payroll compliance history.

Rate your experiences on Rate My Professor or explore secure roles via adjunct professor jobs.

Photo by 0xk on Unsplash

Future Implications Amid University Merger

As University of Adelaide merges into the new Adelaide University, backed by $460 million state funding, lessons from this scandal loom large. Enhanced governance could foster trust, but NTEU urges pre-merger audits. For the sector, federal reforms may simplify agreements, benefiting all.HCAMag details remediation.

In Summary

The University of Adelaide underpayment saga underscores vulnerabilities in casual academic employment, yet proactive remediation offers a path forward. Stay informed, verify entitlements, and share insights on Rate My Professor. Searching for stable roles? Browse higher ed jobs, university jobs, or higher ed career advice on AcademicJobs.com to advance securely.