Growing Criticism of New Zealand's Student Loan System Hits University Students and Higher Education Hard

Understanding New Zealand's Student Loan Scheme in Higher Education

The New Zealand Student Loan Scheme, commonly known as the NZSLS or StudyLink loans, is a government-backed program designed to make tertiary education accessible. Administered initially through StudyLink for applications and disbursements, and later through Inland Revenue Department (IRD) for repayments, it allows eligible New Zealand citizens and permanent residents to borrow money for approved courses at universities, polytechnics, and other tertiary providers. Loans cover three main areas: course fees, course-related costs like books or computers, and living allowances for full-time students.

To qualify, students must be enrolled in Tertiary Education Commission (TEC)-approved programs, typically at least 0.3 Equivalent Full-Time Student (EFTS) load. Once approved, funds are paid directly to the provider for fees and to the student for living costs. For New Zealand-based borrowers, loans are interest-free—a policy introduced in 2006 to ease the burden. However, if a borrower lives overseas for more than 183 days in any 12-month period, interest begins accruing six months after departure, currently at around 4.9% for the 2026 financial year. Repayments start automatically via PAYE when income exceeds the threshold of $24,128 annually, at 12% of earnings above that level. This threshold was frozen in Budget 2025, sparking debate over its fairness amid stagnant wages.

In the context of higher education, the scheme underpins university attendance. With around 43,000 university graduates annually from eight public universities like the University of Auckland and University of Otago, most rely on it to fund bachelor's, master's, or doctoral studies. Yet, as debt mounts, questions arise about whether it truly supports equitable access to university education or creates long-term barriers.

Shocking Scale of Student Debt in 2026

As of September 2025, New Zealanders owe a staggering $16.19 billion across 618,798 borrowers under the scheme. The average balance stands at $26,168, while the median is $17,529—both up significantly from 2013 levels of $19,216 average and $13,358 median. New Zealand-based borrowers number 504,738 with $11.85 billion owed, but overseas-based ones (114,060) hold $4.34 billion, with balances 62% higher at $38,049 average.

Overdue debt totals $2.57 billion, 93% from overseas borrowers ($2.39 billion). Repayment compliance is 82.2% overall, but drops to 23.6% for those abroad—down from 41.5% in 2013. Annual repayments hit $1.64 billion in 2025, yet arrears grow due to penalties and interest. For university graduates, this translates to an average debt of around $26,075 upon leaving, taking roughly five years to clear for NZ-based workers.

• Total borrowers down 15% from 2017 peak, but debt stable at ~$16B due to new borrowing and overseas interest.
• 121,779 new borrowers in 2025, mostly for university-level study.
• University students borrow ~$9,000-12,000 yearly for fees and living costs at institutions like Victoria University of Wellington.

Core Criticisms Fueling the Debate

Criticism of the NZ student loan system has intensified in 2026, particularly regarding its impact on higher education. ACT leader David Seymour highlighted in his State of the Nation speech how high debt, low wages, and taxes trap young graduates. Greens argue inflated debt prevents Kiwis abroad from returning, with 78% of surveyed overseas borrowers making no repayment progress. Experts like Dave Ananth call for discretionary interest waivers to avoid punishing short-term expatriates.

University students face unique pressures: rising living costs in cities like Auckland exacerbate living allowance shortfalls, while frozen repayment thresholds hit early-career academics hardest. Reports from RNZ note overdue repayments exceeding $2.2 billion, questioning scheme sustainability. Stakeholders, including Universities New Zealand, worry debt deters enrollment in costly fields like medicine or engineering at top unis.

The Overseas Borrower Trap and Brain Drain

A major flashpoint is the policy shift for overseas borrowers. Six months post-departure, interest kicks in, compounding at ~5%, ballooning debts. With 18% of borrowers abroad owing 27% of total debt, low compliance (only 1 in 4 paying) stems from high living costs overseas and perceived unfairness. A Green Party survey found inflexible terms drive defaults, costing taxpayers via unrecovered funds.

This affects higher ed profoundly: many university grads pursue international PhDs or jobs, only to face escalating debts deterring returns. For instance, a University of Canterbury engineering grad abroad might see $30,000 debt grow to $40,000+ in two years. Calls for reform include interest holidays or income-contingent rates aligned with NZ wages. Linking to higher ed career advice can help grads plan global moves without loan pitfalls.

StudyLink Delays: A Persistent Headache for Uni Students

Operational woes at StudyLink plague university starters. Processing delays—sometimes weeks into the academic year—leave students unable to pay rent or fees, as reported by RNZ in 2025. Thousands of applications linger unprocessed despite record volumes, with providers like Massey University noting communication glitches.

For 2026 intakes at unis like AUT or Lincoln, late approvals mean bridging loans or hardship funds. Reddit threads echo frustrations: applications from early February still pending by March. StudyLink urges pre-December 16 applications, but volumes overwhelm. This erodes trust, potentially discouraging prospective students from university pathways.

Photo by Athithan Vignakaran on Unsplash

Debt's Ripple Effects on University Access and Choice

Does debt deter university enrollment? While overall tertiary participation lags global trends, university spots remain competitive. Fees-free first-year policy (now shifting to final-year $12,000 cap) reduced borrowing initially, but total debt persists. Students weigh $40,000+ degrees against ROI, opting for cheaper polytech options or delaying study amid 2026 recession.

High youth unemployment—double for grads—amplifies burdens. A Stuff report notes grads face triple whammy: job scarcity, $26k debt, wealth gap. This impacts fields like education or research, where salaries hover near thresholds. Explore university jobs to see entry-level academia salaries barely covering repayments.

Equity Gaps: Māori and Pacific Students in Higher Ed

Disparities hit hardest in higher ed. Māori graduates face nearly double odds of borrowing and 15% higher debt levels than peers, per studies. Pacific students report barriers like family obligations clashing with allowances. Lower incomes post-graduation prolong repayments, widening gaps.

• Māori income advantage from degrees exists but eroded by debt.
• Pacific uni grads cite loan issues buying materials, affecting completion at unis like Waikato.
• Targeted support needed for equitable university access.

Economic Pressures and Post-Grad Realities

In 2026's tough economy, grads enter with debts amid stagnant funding. Budget freezes exacerbate: economists split on threshold halt saving $300M but burdening low-earners. University lecturers or researchers earn ~$80k starting, but adjuncts struggle. Professor salaries improve later, yet early careers suffer.

Government Responses and Proposed Reforms

Government tweaks include final-year fees free up to $12k for first-time tertiary students, aiming to boost completion. Overseas interest rises to 4.9%, with penalties at 8.9%, to curb arrears. Critics like Verian Group urge sustainable fixes: flexible repayments, tech upgrades for StudyLink.

Parliamentary reports eye threshold indexing resumption post-recession. Unis advocate loan forgiveness for shortage areas like STEM lecturing.

Voices from the Frontlines: Student and Expert Perspectives

University students share stories: a Otago med student delayed return from UK rotations due to $50k debt growth. Experts propose: harmonize rates, add grace periods. Unis NZ emphasizes degrees' $1.37M lifetime earnings premium, but debt delays homeownership, families.

Photo by Sung Jin Cho on Unsplash

Pathways Forward: Solutions for Sustainable Higher Ed Finance

To reform, consider:

• Discretionary interest waivers for returnees.
• AI-driven StudyLink processing.
• Equity scholarships for Māori/Pacific uni students.
• Tie thresholds to wage growth.

Check scholarships or higher ed jobs to offset debts. Rate professors at Rate My Professor for informed choices. Career advice at higher ed career advice guides repayment strategies.