The Shocking Sentencing in the Sister Murder Rolex Case

A London court has handed down a life sentence with a minimum term of 22 years to Nancy Pexton for the brutal murder of her younger sister, Jennifer Abbott, and the theft of her prized diamond-encrusted gold Rolex watch. The case, which unfolded in Camden, north London, has captivated the public with its tale of familial betrayal, jealousy, and cold-blooded violence between two elderly sisters.

Pexton, aged 70, stabbed her 69-year-old sister 10 times in a ferocious attack on June 10, 2025, at Abbott's flat in Mornington Place. The victim, a film director also known as Jennifer Abbott Dauward or Sarah Steinberg, was left partially undressed on the living room floor, her mouth sealed with gaffer tape in what the judge described as a deliberate act of degradation. Pexton then fled with the Rolex, a cherished gift from Abbott's son that the victim never removed.

Detailed Timeline of Events Leading to the Murder

The sequence of events began innocently enough on the morning of June 10, 2025. Jennifer Abbott, a routine dog walker, was captured on her doorbell camera returning home at 7:36 a.m. with her beloved corgi, Prince. Later, at 11:36 a.m., she received a phone call from her sister Nancy Pexton. Shortly after, Pexton boarded a bus to Camden, arriving at the flat around 12:45 p.m. CCTV footage confirmed her entry and departure approximately one hour later, at about 1:45 p.m. This was the last confirmed sighting of Abbott alive.

Three days passed without word from Abbott. On June 13, her niece, Mai Pexton, grew concerned and began banging on the door, shouting "auntie." With no response, a neighbor used a scaffolding pole to force entry. Inside, they discovered Abbott's body on the living room floor, marred by multiple stab wounds, a deep slash across her neck, and gaffer tape over her mouth. Emergency services pronounced her dead at the scene.

• June 10, 2025: Pexton visits flat; murder occurs.
• June 13, 2025: Body discovered by niece and neighbor.
• June 18, 2025: Pexton arrested in hospital.
• April 29, 2026: Guilty verdict at Old Bailey.
• May 1, 2026: Life sentence with 22-year minimum.

Profiles of the Sisters: A Tale of Diverging Paths

Jennifer Abbott led a relatively stable life in her Camden flat. As a US citizen and film director, she enjoyed creative pursuits and the companionship of her dog. Her son, Brad Carlson, gifted her the Rolex, symbolizing their close bond. Abbott's life, though private, appeared secure compared to her sister's.

Nancy Pexton, born on April 10, 1956, was homeless at the time of the murder, with no fixed address, though previously associated with Gloucester Place in Westminster. Months prior, digital messages revealed deep-seated resentment. Pexton felt unappreciated and harbored jealousy over Abbott's financial stability. Brad Carlson testified via video link: "There was interaction and sometimes anger and hostility between my mother and Nancy, there was resentment seemingly bubbling up."

Notes on Pexton's phone explicitly referenced plans to kill her sister, and Abbott herself had messaged concerns about Pexton's intentions. This history of animosity set the stage for the tragic outcome.

The Brutal Attack: Forensic Details Emerge

The post-mortem revealed 10 stab wounds, including a severe slash to the neck. Gaffer tape bound Abbott's mouth, with Pexton's DNA confirmed on it. Blood soaked Pexton's dungarees and cowboy hat, which she later claimed resulted from hugging Abbott during a nosebleed—an implausible defense debunked by forensics. The Rolex, missing from the scene, was recovered from Pexton's hospital bag.

Judge Tan Ikram at the Old Bailey described the attack's "ferocity" as proof of intent to kill. The gaffer tape was "a deliberate act of degradation, callous, demeaning, and cruel," reflecting profound hostility. For more on the forensic process, see the Metropolitan Police statement.

Investigation and Dramatic Hospital Arrest

Detectives quickly focused on Pexton as the last visitor. On June 18, after she called her GP claiming an overdose, she was hospitalized. Bodycam footage captured her arrest in her hospital bed. The Rolex was found in her bag; she claimed Abbott gave it to her to "look after." Pexton's lies unraveled under scrutiny from Detective Inspector Barry Hart: "The evidence uncovered during this investigation tells a different story."

The probe involved CCTV analysis, phone records, and digital forensics, leading to charges on June 20, 2025.

Photo by Shahzin Shajid on Unsplash

The Trial: Evidence Overwhelms Defense

At the Old Bailey, prosecutors painted a picture of premeditated murder driven by jealousy. Defense claims of accident or self-defense collapsed against CCTV, DNA, and incriminating notes. The jury deliberated briefly before convicting on April 29, 2026. Crown Prosecution Service's Devi Kharran noted Pexton's "brutal and callous attack."

Judge's Stern Remarks and No Remorse

Sentencing Judge Dhir stated: "Your actions and conduct after the killing demonstrates not only your absence of remorse but also a deliberate and callous attitude towards what you had done." She highlighted the theft as motivated by value and envy: "You took the watch because it was valuable and because you were jealous of your sister’s greater financial security." Life imprisonment ensures justice, though scars remain.

Family's Heartbreaking Loss and Statements

Brad Carlson's testimony underscored years of tension. Mai Pexton's role in discovery amplified the family's trauma. No full statements post-sentencing, but DI Hart acknowledged: "While no sentence can undo the devastation caused to Jennifer’s family and friends..."

Sibling Violence in Context: Rare but Devastating

Sibling murders are uncommon but profoundly shocking. In the UK, domestic homicides claim around 100 lives annually, with 70% female victims, per Office for National Statistics data year ending March 2023. Older adults (over 60) account for about one in four domestic killings, often involving long-simmering resentments like jealousy over resources.

This case exemplifies how financial disparity and homelessness can exacerbate familial rifts, even in later life. Elderly crime rates are low overall, but when they occur, they often stem from intimate relationships.

Public Reaction and Media Frenzy

The story trended across UK media, from BBC to tabloids like The Sun and Mirror, highlighting the Rolex theft's audacity. Social media buzzed with outrage over the betrayal. Discussions on platforms like Reddit focused on mental health and support for homeless elderly, though Pexton's lack of remorse drew condemnation.

Photo by LOGAN WEAVER | @LGNWVR on Unsplash

Lessons and Prevention: Addressing Family Violence

This tragedy underscores the need for early intervention in familial disputes. UK Domestic Homicide Reviews emphasize risk assessment in older domestic cases. Charities like Refuge and government hotlines offer support. Policymakers may review elderly homelessness links to crime. For resources, visit gov.uk domestic homicide analysis.

Communities must foster dialogue, especially among aging siblings facing inequality. While justice is served, prevention remains key.