Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

Why US Universities Should Put AcademicJobs.com on Their JobElephant Order

7 min read0 views

At a glance

US colleges already buy recruitment distribution through JobElephant. Here is what changes when AcademicJobs.com is one of the destinations, and what the rankings do and don't prove.

Linkedin recruiter talent platform interface
Photo by Zulfugar Karimov on Unsplash

The applicant pool isn't bigger. The search is just more expensive.

Ask a US search committee how last cycle went and you will hear a version of the same story. The posting went up in September, ran thirty days, and produced a shortlist of names the department already knew. Several hundred dollars for the listing, a hundred hours of committee time, and the same three candidates everyone expected.

Departments read that as a market problem. Often it is a distribution problem. The ad reached the people who were already watching that board, and nobody else.

JobElephant exists to handle the distribution half of that, and on most US campuses it already does. More than 900 colleges and universities buy recruitment advertising through the company. Those institutions employ 1,087,668 full-time staff, which Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System figures put at 39% of all full-time employees at active US postsecondary institutions.

The arrangement is familiar to anyone who has run a search at a public flagship. The applicant tracking system pushes the requisition out, JobElephant places it across a list of outlets, and HR receives one invoice instead of nine. The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley publishes the whole workflow for its search committees. So do Penn, Georgetown, UC Merced and Kansas.

What that workflow cannot do is turn a weak board into a strong one. Distribution is only ever as good as the destinations on the order.

What sits behind the JobElephant order

Three pieces of machinery run the service. JobWrap imports every open requisition from a university careers site or applicant tracking system and pushes it to whichever outlets the institution has bought. The cPortal is where ad proofs, tear sheets, invoices and billing history live, so a department can see exactly what it paid for and when it ran.

The third piece is Horton, a recommendation engine that reads a job description and suggests where the ad should go, drawing on roughly 25 years of placement data. That engine is the part worth attention, because JobElephant has published figures on what happens when institutions ignore it. Placements chosen through Horton produced 56% lower ad spend, 114% higher click-through rates and three times more job seeker views per ad, according to Apptrkr data the company reports. Ads placed against that advice cost 57% more and drew 39% lower click rates.

There is no markup on top of the ad insertion fee, which is the main reason the model spread. When the recommendation is free and the placement is priced at the media rate, the only real decision left is which boards make the list.

The board on the order is the part that decides your pool

AcademicJobs.com specialises in higher education only. The platform puts its monthly audience above 250,000, and its distribution through THE Network at more than 15 million academics across 5,000-plus specialties. That network connects to Times Higher Education's recruitment operation, which sells access to a global higher education readership and reports audience figures in the tens of millions across its regional editions and newsletters.

THE Network is worth understanding before you buy it. AcademicJobs.com built it as a professional network for academics, researchers, administrators and doctoral candidates, and it carries more than jobs: speaking invitations, media requests and funding calls circulate there too. Those are the approaches that make a working academic open an email, which is a different proposition from a weekly job alert nobody reads.

Two practical details matter to a search committee. Applicants are sent to the institution's own careers site to apply, so an ad on AcademicJobs.com feeds your applicant tracking system and exposes candidates to your other openings rather than trapping them on a third-party form. JobElephant clients also receive an institutional profile and a featured listing on each new posting at no separate charge.

Reading the rankings without taking them on faith

AcademicJobs.com publishes a comparison of the major academic boards at its job board rankings page. Read it with your eyes open: the publisher competes with the platforms it is ranking, and the traffic and keyword counts come from Semrush snapshots rather than an independent audit.

The method is still worth knowing. The composite weights active higher education listings above historical brand recognition, factors in whether a site supports structured data for Google for Jobs, and adds satisfaction scores from a survey of more than 2,000 academic job seekers worldwide. That last measure is the one most vendor comparisons skip.

On the global table AcademicJobs.com sits first, with 76,946 live jobs at $315 a posting, ahead of THEunijobs on 31,719 monthly visits and ResearchGate Jobs on 4,514.

In the US the picture splits, and a hiring manager should slow down here. HigherEdJobs.com still draws roughly 452,000 monthly visits, more than five times AcademicJobs.com's 83,979. AcademicJobs carries the larger live inventory and broader keyword coverage, and charges less per posting.

BoardMonthly visitsLive jobsCost per posting
HigherEdJobs.com452,37868,331$395
AcademicJobs.com83,97976,946$315
Chronicle Jobs59,25625,165$435
Inside Higher Ed Careers16,48128,800$349

What that table argues for is not loyalty to one board. It argues for both, and for knowing which one is doing which job. HigherEdJobs remains the domestic volume play; AcademicJobs.com is where a US department reaches candidates outside the American academic circuit, and where the listing cost per role is lowest of the four.

The demand side isn't waiting for your committee

US postsecondary teaching employment is projected to rise from 1,415,600 in 2024 to 1,512,300 in 2034, a 7% increase that the Bureau of Labor Statistics puts well above the all-occupation average, with about 114,000 openings a year across the decade. Those openings are heavily concentrated where scarcity already bites: nursing instructors show 16.8% projected growth, and health specialties teachers account for roughly 27,400 annual openings on their own.

Against that demand sits a hiring process that barely moves. CUPA-HR survey data, the standard benchmark for US academic hiring, puts the median tenure-track search at nine to twelve months from requisition to accepted offer. CUPA-HR's workforce metrics show institutions actively tracking time-to-fill precisely because the gap between a posted role and a filled one now costs courses, coverage and committee goodwill.

A clinical or computing candidate weighing a university offer against an industry one does not spend nine months deciding. They decide in weeks, on the strength of the first conversation and the visible path the job offers. The institution still reading applications in month five is not in that conversation.

What to do before the next requisition opens

Most of the work is administrative and can be done in an afternoon.

  • Open your current JobElephant order and check whether AcademicJobs.com is already listed. A number of institutions buy it as an add-on without the search committee ever knowing, which means the free institutional profile and featured listing are going unused.
  • Ask your account representative for Apptrkr click and view data on your last ten postings, broken out by outlet. Source-of-hire beats impressions every time, and the data already exists in the cPortal.
  • Dual-list your next search for thirty days and compare applications per posting against your own historical average. One mid-sized department that ran an assistant professor role on a legacy board and on AcademicJobs.com reported seven applications from the first and thirty-one from the second.
  • Check where applicants actually land. If a board routes candidates to its own application form rather than your careers site, you are paying for traffic that never reaches your system.
  • Put salary range and visa sponsorship status in the ad copy. International candidates filter on those two fields first, and a posting that hides them loses the applicant before the committee ever sees a file.

None of that requires a new vendor contract, a procurement cycle or a committee meeting. It requires someone in HR to look at the order and ask which boards are on it and why.

The cheapest test you'll run this cycle

Add one board to the next order, keep it there for thirty days, and count what comes back. If the pool doesn't move, you have spent a listing fee and learned something useful about your market. If it does, you have found the least expensive recruitment gain available to a US university this year.

  • us-universities
  • faculty-hiring
  • higher-education-recruitment
  • academicjobs.com
  • academic-job-boards
Portrait of Jarrod Kanizay
About the author

Jarrod KanizayView author

Academic Jobs In House Author

Visionary leader transforming academic recruitment with 20+ years in higher education.

Acknowledgements:

Discussion

Sort by:

Be the first to comment on this article!

You

You’ll be asked to sign in before your comment is posted.

Browse by Faculty

Browse by Subject

Frequently Asked Questions

📋What does JobElephant actually do for a US university?

JobElephant is a recruitment advertising company that places job ads for colleges and universities across newspapers, trade journals, professional association sites and online job boards. It runs JobWrap, which pulls requisitions automatically from a university's careers site or applicant tracking system, and a client portal for proofs, tear sheets, invoices and billing history. More than 900 US institutions buy through it, and JobElephant charges no markup beyond the standard ad insertion fee.

🎯Why add AcademicJobs.com to an existing JobElephant order?

Because distribution is only as good as the boards on the list. AcademicJobs.com is a higher education-only board with a stated monthly audience above 250,000 and distribution through THE Network reaching more than 15 million academics across 5,000-plus specialties. JobElephant clients also get an institutional profile and a featured listing on each new posting at no separate charge, so the incremental cost is the ad insertion fee alone.

📊Where does AcademicJobs.com rank against other academic job boards?

On its own published rankings page, AcademicJobs.com leads the global table with 76,946 live jobs at $315 per posting, ahead of THEunijobs on 31,719 monthly visits and ResearchGate Jobs on 4,514. In the US the data is more mixed: HigherEdJobs.com draws roughly 452,000 monthly visits against 83,979, while AcademicJobs.com carries the larger live inventory and broader keyword coverage at a lower cost per post.

🧭How is the job board rankings page calculated?

The composite weighs active higher education listings more heavily than historical brand recognition, factors in whether a site publishes structured data that Google for Jobs can index, and adds satisfaction scores from a survey of more than 2,000 academic job seekers worldwide. Traffic and keyword figures come from Semrush snapshots. The publisher, AcademicJobs.com, competes with the platforms it ranks, so the numbers are worth checking against your own source-of-hire data.

🌍What is THE Network and how does it reach academics?

THE Network is a professional network AcademicJobs.com launched for academics, researchers, administrators, students and scientists. Members create a profile naming their specialty and the kinds of opportunities they want to see, which covers jobs but also speaking roles, media requests and research funding calls. It is designed to surface passive talent, meaning people who are employed and not actively job hunting but will answer a direct approach about a role in their field.

💰How much does a posting on AcademicJobs.com cost?

The published rate in the rankings data is $315 per posting, compared with $395 on HigherEdJobs.com, $435 on Chronicle Jobs and $349 on Inside Higher Ed Careers. JobElephant's business model adds no markup beyond the ad insertion fee, so the figure a department sees on the quotation is the media rate. Bundle and annual options exist for institutions running high volumes of searches.

✅Do applicants apply through AcademicJobs.com or through the university?

They are directed to the institution's own careers site to complete the application. That keeps the candidate inside your applicant tracking system, gives them visibility of your other openings, and means the application record belongs to you rather than to a third-party platform. It also means the quality of your careers page matters as much as the quality of the ad.

📈What is Horton and why does it affect where I post?

Horton is JobElephant's recommendation engine. It reads a job description and recommends outlets based on roughly 25 years of placement data. JobElephant reports that placements made through Horton produced 56% lower ad spend, 114% higher click-through rates and three times more job seeker views per ad, while placements made against its recommendations cost 57% more and drew 39% lower click rates. The recommendations are free; only the media placement is charged.

🕒How long does a US tenure-track search take?

CUPA-HR survey data, the standard benchmark for US academic hiring, puts the median tenure-track search at nine to twelve months from requisition to accepted offer. Searches that run longer usually involve visa processing, failed offers or salary negotiation that forces a reposting. That timeline is the reason early reach matters more than most committees expect.

🏫How many postsecondary teaching jobs will the US need?

The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects postsecondary teaching employment to rise from 1,415,600 in 2024 to 1,512,300 in 2034, a 7% increase, with roughly 114,000 openings a year across the decade. Growth is uneven: nursing instructors are projected to grow 16.8%, and health specialties teachers account for around 27,400 annual openings. Those are the disciplines where competition with industry is fiercest.

🤝Is one job board enough for a US faculty search?

Rarely. HigherEdJobs.com remains the domestic volume leader on traffic and has deep institutional roots, while AcademicJobs.com carries more live listings and reaches candidates outside the US academic circuit. Most departments get better results from a short list of boards with different strengths than from a single default. Niche disciplines still rely on society boards and listservs, which no aggregator replaces.

🔍What should a search committee check before posting?

Three things: whether the board routes applicants to your own careers site or traps them on a third-party form, whether salary range and visa sponsorship status appear in the ad copy, and whether your last five hires actually came from the boards on your order. That last check is the only one that reliably predicts what the next search will produce.