Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

Academic Salary Benchmarking When the Market Moves Faster Than the Budget

11 min read0 views

At a glance

University compensation and talent acquisition teams are benchmarking academic pay against peers while budgets tighten and discipline-level market rates shift. A practical look at peer group design, total value comparison and what transparency rules now demand.

Miniature person sitting on stack of coins reading newspaper
Photo by Mathieu Stern on Unsplash

Compensation teams went into this year's cycle holding a number that looked defensible on paper. Average full-time faculty salaries in the United States rose 2.3 percent between fall 2024 and fall 2025, according to preliminary results from the American Association of University Professors' annual Faculty Compensation Survey. Consumer prices rose 2.7 percent over the same period. Real pay fell 0.4 percent, and average full-time salaries sit roughly 9.5 percent below where they were in fall 2019 once inflation is stripped out.

The College and University Professional Association for Human Resources (CUPA-HR) tells the same story from a different angle. In its 2025-26 workforce data, tenure-track faculty received a median increase of 1.8 percent — the smallest of any employee group, and the fourth year running they have finished last. In real terms, tenure-track salaries are 11.7 percent below 2019-20 levels. Across the ten years CUPA-HR has tracked, tenure-track increases have never once beaten inflation.

Employee groupMedian increase, 2025-26Real change vs 2019-20
Non-exempt staff3.0%minus 0.9%
Administrators2.9%not reported in the summary
Professionals2.8%not reported in the summary
Non-tenure-track faculty2.0%minus 6.8%
Tenure-track faculty1.8%minus 11.7%
Consumer price index2.7%reference point

None of that answers the question a hiring manager actually has on a Tuesday afternoon: what do we offer an associate professor of accounting at a mid-sized public university, in a city where living costs have climbed faster than the pay spine? A national median is a starting point and nothing more. The work of academic salary benchmarking is building the comparator that answers that question, then being able to explain in writing why the answer is fair.

Peer groups decide the answer before the data arrives

Ask a compensation office which peers it uses and you learn more about the institution than any salary table will tell you. The peer group sets the target, which is why most institutions settle on a fixed set and defend it for years.

Iowa State University works from three groups: ten peer institutions designated by the Iowa Board of Regents, a 29-institution set submitted to the federal Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS), and a group drawn from institutions in the fourth quartile for total expenses. Virginia Tech follows an ordered sequence when data are thin — the group set by the State Council of Higher Education for Virginia first, then public land-grant universities, then doctoral institutions with total expenses above $900 million. The University of Central Florida reviews its peers formally every two years, with the president, provost, chief analytics officer and chief human resources officer all in the room.

The details matter more than the labels. Wake Forest University applies local cost-of-living data alongside national academic peers, because national benchmarks alone would push its targets too high for its region. UCF does something similar from the opposite direction: sitting in the Orlando metro area, it often finds national academic peers too low to be competitive and pulls in local market data instead. Virginia Tech keeps an aspirational group on hand, private doctoral institutions nationwide, and reaches for it when a specific role has chronic turnover.

There is a governance dimension too. A 2026 study in the Journal of Information Systems Applied Research criticised the common practice of building separate peer groups for base salaries and for high-demand disciplines, arguing that subjective filters and post-hoc additions such as aspirational institutions invite equity challenges. The authors proposed a single peer group built from stakeholder-identified variables such as enrolment, finances and student outcomes, deliberately excluding salary data. The principle holds either way: if the peer group can be redrawn after the numbers arrive, nobody will trust the numbers.

Discipline is the pay band that actually moves

Institution-wide averages hide the only variation that drives offers. CUPA-HR's twenty-year analysis of faculty pay by discipline found business faculty were the highest-paid discipline for nine consecutive years and recorded the largest median salary increase of any field, 66.2 percent, between 2003-04 and 2023-24. Health professions more than doubled its faculty headcount over the same period. English language and literature ranked among the ten lowest-paid disciplines every year and has roughly 40 percent of its faculty off the tenure track.

The finding that should stop a compensation lead cold is this one: no discipline's median salary kept pace with inflation across those two decades. Not one. A benchmark that says your department is at market may still be describing a slow real-terms cut, and telling a candidate that is very different from telling them they are being paid competitively. The CUPA-HR report sets out the discipline-level numbers in full.

Then there is the internal damage external benchmarking leaves behind. Salary compression is when junior and senior colleagues end up too close together; inversion is when the new hire earns more than the people who will mentor them. Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB) data cited in a study of the problem showed newly hired assistant professors in business arriving at 2 percent above incumbent assistants, and new doctorates hired at rates 10 percent above current assistants, 8 percent above current associates and only about 7 percent below current full professors. By 2008 the gap between full and associate professors had narrowed to 13 percent while the gap between associates and assistants was just 2 percent. The market sets the entry price. The internal ladder sets everything above it, usually years out of date.

Jacqueline Bichsel, CUPA-HR's associate vice president of research, put the practical consequence plainly: for many faculty the only chance at a significant rise is promotion, and even those events are now producing smaller increases than expected, as she told Inside Higher Ed. A benchmark that ignores the promotion step is not measuring a career. It is measuring a starting line.

The band is the smallest part of the offer

Where the pay spine is negotiated collectively, the headline percentage is only one lever. In the United Kingdom, the Universities and Colleges Employers Association (UCEA) made a final offer of 1.4 percent from 1 August 2025 for the institutions it represents, alongside removal of the bottom two spine points, and noted that around half of staff would also be eligible for an increment worth up to 3 percent. That increment, not the headline, is what a new starter experiences in year one. The full 2025-26 round is documented by UCEA, including the union claim of RPI plus 3.5 percent or a flat £2,500, and the joint work on spine reform that followed.

In Australia the same logic plays out through enterprise agreements, which lock in classification rates, loadings and allowances for the life of the agreement. RMIT University's 2024 agreement runs to a nominal expiry of 31 December 2026 and defines full rate of pay to include all loadings and allowances. Benchmarking there is really bargaining preparation: the comparison you build this year becomes the evidence you table two years from now.

Geography is the adjustment most often done badly. Tufts University's faculty market analysis, run with Willis Towers Watson, drew on CUPA-HR's national faculty survey using custom peer groups and then applied a 14 percent geographic cost-of-labor differential for Boston, sourced from ERI survey data as of 1 April 2025. Tufts also said plainly that most institutions phase the resulting salary changes over three to five years. The methodology is published in full, which is rather the point.

And the part of the offer that never makes it into the pay band: pensions, leave, contract security, teaching load. Among 555 institutions reporting starting rates for part-time faculty in the AAUP's survey, the median was $3,121 per course section. Only 32.7 percent contributed to retirement for some or all of those faculty, and 30.6 percent contributed to medical cover. Candidates read those numbers before they read the salary.

Transparency is turning the benchmark into a published document

For institutions operating in the European Union, benchmarking has stopped being an internal exercise. Directive (EU) 2023/970 on pay transparency carried a transposition deadline of 7 June 2026. It requires employers to give applicants the starting salary or a salary range before the interview, and forbids asking about pay history. It also requires pay structures built on objective, gender-neutral criteria assessed against four factors: skills, responsibility, effort and working conditions.

The European Commission and the European Institute for Gender Equality published detailed guidance in March 2026, including a default points framework that weights skills at 40 percent, responsibility at 35 percent, effort at 15 percent and working conditions at 10 percent, for a maximum of 1,200 points. Each 10 percent band of the total score is meant to define a comparable category of workers. Lewis Silkin's analysis sets out how the framework is expected to operate in practice.

Reporting starts at 7 June 2027 for employers with 250 or more staff, on an annual cycle, with smaller employers phased in to 2031. Where a reported gap of 5 percent or more in any category cannot be justified on objective grounds and is not fixed within six months, the employer must run a joint pay assessment with worker representatives. The burden of proof sits with the employer.

Read that alongside your peer benchmarking and the risk is obvious. If the answer to why one role pays less than another is that the peers pay it that way, the peer data had better be current, documented and applied consistently. Benchmarking data is now evidence.

Selling the role when salary is not the ceiling

Most institutions cannot win a bidding war for a clinical psychologist or a machine-learning lecturer, and pretending otherwise wastes everyone's time. What they can do is stop hiding the parts of the offer candidates genuinely weigh: whether the contract is continuing, how progression works, what the teaching load is, whether sessional staff have a conversion route, and what the pension is worth.

Two changes do most of the work. Publish the band, with a stated midpoint and a clear account of what moves someone through it, which turns a negotiation into a conversation. Then name the ceiling honestly and say what sits beside it. A candidate comparing a 12-month contract at a lower salary against a continuing post with a documented workload model is not comparing salaries at all.

The pattern on the candidate side is consistent: ads that withhold the range get fewer serious applicants, and the ones who do apply arrive with a number in mind that nobody has corrected. There is more on this in how employer branding works in higher education recruitment, and it applies whether you are hiring one lecturer or forty.

A benchmarking checklist that survives a scrutiny panel

None of this is complicated. It is just frequently skipped.

  • Fix the peer group in writing before you pull any data, use the same set for every role in the exercise, and publish it.
  • Record the fallback sequence for roles where data are thin — narrow group first, then broader, then local market. Virginia Tech's written methodology is the model.
  • Match on discipline code, rank and tenure status rather than on department name. The University of Louisville's study used Classification of Instructional Programs (CIP) codes, and fell back to professional association surveys for dentistry, medicine, nursing and librarians where the national faculty survey lacked the detail.
  • Age every data set to your decision date using a documented cost-of-labor adjustment, not cost of living.
  • Benchmark total cash, not base only: market supplements, clinical loadings, stipends and sessional rates all change the comparison.
  • Apply a geographic differential that is sourced and dated, and say which city it refers to.
  • Run a compression and inversion check before you make the offer, not after the incumbent complains.
  • Report the share of your population within 10 percent of market and within 5 percent. A consultancy rule of thumb applied in the University of Central Arkansas study treats within 10 percent as competitive, within 5 percent as highly competitive, below 90 percent as possible misalignment and below 85 percent as significant misalignment.
  • Test the result for a 5 percent gap by category, with worker representatives in the room, before a regulator asks.
  • Write the method down in plain language and put it where faculty can read it.

What to do on Monday

Pick the peer group, write down why it is the right one, and give the same set to every hiring manager in the institution. Then take the roles you have been struggling to fill and check what your own data says against the market for the discipline, at that rank, in that city. If the gap is wider than 10 percent, that is not a recruitment problem. It is a budget decision somebody has been avoiding, and no job ad will fix it.

  • higher-education-recruitment
  • faculty-pay
  • cupa-hr
  • pay-transparency
  • pay-bands
Portrait of Jarrod Kanizay
About the author

Jarrod KanizayView author

Academic Jobs In House Author

Visionary leader transforming academic recruitment with 20+ years in higher education.

Discussion

Sort by:

Be the first to comment on this article!

You

You’ll be asked to sign in before your comment is posted.

Frequently Asked Questions

●What is academic salary benchmarking?

It is the process of comparing what an institution pays for a defined academic role against what comparable institutions pay for the same work. A sound exercise fixes four things before any data are pulled: the peer group, the matching method (usually discipline code plus rank plus tenure status), the data source, and the adjustment applied for geography and for the age of the data. The output is not a single number but a position — typically expressed as a percentage of the market median — that a hiring manager can defend to a dean, a union and, increasingly, a regulator.

●How many peer institutions should a university use?

There is no universal number, but published methodologies tend to land between ten and thirty. Iowa State University uses three fixed groups, one of ten institutions designated by its Board of Regents and a wider 29-institution IPEDS set. Tufts University's market study used a university-wide comparator list of twenty institutions, with separate groups for its veterinary and nutrition schools. What matters more than the count is that the group is chosen on criteria that have nothing to do with salary, that it is reviewed on a stated cycle, and that it is applied consistently across every role in the exercise.

●Should we benchmark base salary or total remuneration?

Both, in that order. Base salary is the only figure that is reliably comparable across institutions, so it drives the band. But candidates and current staff compare the whole package, and the gaps there are large. In the AAUP's survey, only 32.7 percent of reporting institutions contributed to retirement plans for some or all of their part-time faculty, and 30.6 percent contributed to medical cover. Add market supplements, clinical loadings, sessional rates, study leave and contract security to your working sheet even if the published benchmark uses base only.

●How should geography be handled in academic pay comparisons?

Use a cost-of-labor differential, not a cost-of-living index, and source and date it. Tufts University applied a 14 percent geographic cost-of-labor differential for Boston in its faculty market analysis, drawn from ERI survey data as of 1 April 2025. Institutions in lower-cost regions face the reverse problem: Wake Forest University uses local data because national academic benchmarks would otherwise set targets above what its regional market supports. Both directions need to be documented, or the adjustment looks like an excuse.

●What is the difference between salary compression and salary inversion?

Compression is when the gap between junior and senior colleagues in the same discipline narrows to the point where experience stops paying. Inversion is the sharper version: a new hire earns more than incumbents at the same rank, or close to colleagues a rank above. Both come from the same source — entry pay tracks the external market while internal progression tracks budgets and tradition. AACSB data cited in a study of the problem showed new business doctorates being hired at rates about 10 percent above incumbent assistant professors and only 7 percent below full professors.

●How often should a university refresh its salary benchmarks?

Annually for the data, every two to three years for the peer group. The University of Central Florida runs a formal peer assessment every two years involving the president, provost, chief analytics officer and chief human resources officer; Iowa State revisits its groups every two to three years or when a classification change forces a revision. Compensation specialists interviewed by CUPA-HR described peer group changes as relatively uncommon, which is the point — stability is what makes year-on-year comparisons meaningful.

●What does the EU Pay Transparency Directive require of universities?

Directive (EU) 2023/970, with a transposition deadline of 7 June 2026, requires employers to disclose the starting salary or a salary range to applicants before interview and bars questions about pay history. Pay structures must rest on objective, gender-neutral criteria covering skills, responsibility, effort and working conditions. Employers with 250 or more staff report gender pay gaps annually from 7 June 2027, with smaller employers phased in to 2031. An unjustified gap of 5 percent or more in any category that is not remedied within six months triggers a joint pay assessment with worker representatives, and the burden of proof sits with the employer.

●How do you benchmark roles that national faculty surveys do not cover?

You layer sources. The University of Louisville's compensation study used CUPA-HR data as its primary source but benchmarked dental, medical and nursing faculty against the ADEA, AAMC and AACN surveys, and librarians against the Association of Research Librarians survey, because the national faculty survey could not match those roles at discipline level. Where no external benchmark exists at all, slot the role against internal comparators and record the reasoning. An undocumented judgement is the thing that gets challenged.

●What counts as competitive against the market?

There is no binding standard, but published institutional targets give a workable frame. In the University of Central Arkansas study, the consultant advised that salaries within 10 percent of market are competitive and within 5 percent highly competitive, that below 90 percent signals possible misalignment and below 85 percent significant misalignment. The university set a goal of bringing every employee to at least 90 percent of market over several budget cycles. Pick a threshold, publish it, and then report honestly against it.

●What should a university do when it cannot match the market rate?

Say so, and then compete on the parts of the offer that are within your control. Publish the band and the midpoint. Explain what moves someone through the range. State the contract type and the progression route in the advertisement rather than at offer stage. Set out the workload model, any sessional conversion commitment, and the pension. A candidate weighing a lower salary against a continuing contract with a documented load is making a rational trade — but only if you give them the information to make it.

●How does AcademicJobs.com help with benchmarking and role positioning?

It gives talent acquisition teams a view of how roles are actually being advertised and priced across the sector, so a pay band can be tested against live market activity rather than survey data alone. That is useful in two directions: checking whether a salary range will attract applicants at the discipline and rank you need, and writing the advertisement so the parts of the offer beyond base salary are visible. Explore current listings and salary pages at AcademicJobs.com before the next hiring round.

Academic Salary Benchmarking: Peer Groups and Pay Ba… #29700