At a glance
OASPA's new DEI guidance asks open access publishers to audit editorial boards, APC waivers and accountability. Here is what it means for journals and authors.
The Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) has released equity, diversity and inclusion guidance for its member publishers. The document lands at a peculiar moment. Open access has largely won the argument about free-to-read science. Scholarly publishing still runs on a gatekeeping economy in which the same small group of institutions holds editorial power, and waivers for publication fees often operate as charitable exceptions rather than structural repair. The guidance asks publishers to treat that gap as a policy failure, not a public relations exercise.
OASPA is the trade body for publishers that make all articles free to read at once. Its membership spans commercial publishers such as PLOS, Frontiers, MDPI and Wiley's Hindawi, alongside dozens of smaller university and society presses. A framework from this group carries weight because member publishers set the article-processing charge (APC), the fee many open access journals charge authors or their funders after acceptance. Those fees shape who can publish as much as who can read.
What the Guidance Asks
The guidance is not a single metric. It is a set of expectations ranging from leadership accountability to the mechanics of a waiver application. Publishers are asked to name an executive responsible for equity outcomes, to review APC waiver criteria against local researcher income rather than country band alone, and to audit editorial board and reviewer demographics where data protection law permits. OASPA also wants publishers to report submission-to-acceptance rates by region, gender and race, and to offer accessible formats alongside plain-language summaries.
Privacy law constrains what publishers can collect. The European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) treats data on race, ethnicity and health as special categories. The guidance therefore points publishers toward voluntary, anonymised collection rather than mandatory identity boxes on submission forms.
The guidance also targets the hidden filters that shape submissions before a paper reaches review. That includes journal websites that default to US date formats, author portals that require a single institutional affiliation, and editorial systems that ask for gender in a fixed binary field. None of these is a grand gesture; together they determine who finds the submission form usable.
Why DEI in Publishing Is Harder Than a Mission Statement
The problems are measurable and old. Editorial boards of many well-known journals remain dominated by researchers in North America and Europe. Peer review relies on volunteer labour that reproduces existing networks. APC waiver programmes frequently ask authors to prove both their country and their funder's limits, a double burden that many authors abandon before they finish the form.
C4DISC, the Coalition for Diversity and Inclusion in Scholarly Communications, has assembled a Joint Statement of Principles that publishers, libraries and funders have signed. UNESCO's Recommendation on Open Science, adopted by member states in November 2021, makes equity a core principle rather than a side project.
Publisher obligations in practice include:
- Publishing the share of editorial board members from low- and middle-income countries, updated annually.
- Reporting the number of APC waiver applications received, approved and denied, with median decision time.
- Disclosing reviewer invitation and acceptance rates by region.
- Auditing whether authors from underrepresented groups receive disproportionately more requests for English language editing.
- Appointing an executive owner for equity outcomes with published annual targets.
These are disclosure requirements more than behavioural mandates. A journal can have a homogeneous board and still report it; the theory is that sunlight changes behaviour faster than sermons.
A board that is 80 percent men from high-income countries can still accept strong research. The problem is what the board misses: studies on local disease burdens, education systems or agricultural practices that reviewers elsewhere do not know are worth citing. Diversity in peer review is not decorative; it changes what counts as quality.
Photo by Annie Spratt on Unsplash
The Waiver Problem
APC waivers are the sharpest test of the guidance's seriousness. Many publishers list waivers as evidence of equity, yet their websites do not disclose the approval rate, the average turnaround time, or the countries most frequently denied. The result is a policy that reads better than it functions. Authors in low- and middle-income countries often wait weeks for a decision that a journal in Germany or the United States never has to request.
Recent reporting on rising APC costs and waiver activism shows that even when waivers are approved, they are increasingly reserved for authors in the lowest income bracket. Middle-income researchers receive a discount that can still exceed a local monthly salary. Index directories such as the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) already ask journals to declare whether they have a waiver policy, but the field does not capture approval rates. As DOAJ has tightened its indexing criteria, there is an opening to add equity metadata.
The waiver form itself can be a barrier. Some publishers require a scanned proof of institutional eligibility, a personal statement, and a supervisor's signature. A researcher who pays for mobile data per megabyte has already lost an afternoon before the application is reviewed.
Here's the Catch
OASPA can publish a framework; it cannot enforce one. Membership requirements cover transparency around peer review and licensing, not the demographic composition of an editorial board or the speed of a waiver decision. A publisher that signs the guidance and then declines to release waiver approval rates faces no material penalty. Soft law works only when buyers, funders and indexers apply pressure, and that pressure is currently uneven.
The publishers most likely to adopt the guidance are the ones already doing the work. PLOS publishes an equity report, eLife removed its significance filter, and some university presses run no-fee diamond journals. The sustainability of those no-fee journals remains fragile, as the European debate over diamond open access funding has shown. A publisher that treats DEI as a dashboard is not the same as one that treats it as a requirement.
Procurement officers in university libraries already negotiate discounts and offsets for read-and-publish agreements. Adding a clause that requires publishers to publish APC waiver approval rates within 120 days of each payment is within their existing competence. The same clause would be far more effective than another statement of support.
Hype Versus Reality
Hype: the industry has embraced equity, diversity and inclusion. Reality: most editorial board diversity data remain unpublished. Hype: APC waivers make publishing fair. Reality: waiver approval rates are rarely audited, and country bands do not track researcher income. The gap runs between publishers that disclose and publishers that do not.
The full OASPA guidance is available on the association's equity, diversity and inclusion page. It invites comment from publishers, librarians and researchers rather than issuing a compliance timetable.
Consider two journals. Journal A publishes an annual EDI report with board demographics, waiver approval rates and median decision times. Journal B includes the word 'inclusive' on its APC waiver page and shares nothing else. The guidance cannot make Journal B transparent, but it gives librarians and authors a shared language for saying no.
What Changes First
The first test is disclosure. A publisher's equity policy matters less than whether it names the executive responsible for APC waiver approvals and publishes the most recent year's data. The second test is speed. Waiver approvals that take three days instead of three weeks change an author's decision to submit. The third test is whether libraries and consortia insert equity requirements into read-and-publish agreements, the contracts that bundle subscription access with fee coverage. The fourth is whether universities stop treating waiver eligibility as a publisher's favour and start listing it as a criterion in their own procurement.
The guidance will ultimately be tested by the author in Nairobi or Lahore who opens a waiver page, sees the asterisk, and emails the editorial office. For that author, a policy is not an announcement. It is the difference between a submission and a silence.
- academic-publishing
- open-access
- open-access-publishing
- editorial-boards
- apc-waivers

