Photo by Erik Mclean on Unsplash
Recent advancements in gender-affirming care have spotlighted a pivotal new study from Canadian researchers, demonstrating that body mass index (BMI)—a standard measure calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared—does not influence postoperative complication rates in masculinizing chest surgery. Published online on January 13, 2026, in the Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, this research challenges longstanding practices where higher BMI often barred patients from surgery.
The study, conducted at an ambulatory facility recognized as a center of excellence in gender-affirming surgery, analyzed data from 530 patients treated between August 2021 and October 2024. With BMI ranging from 16.1 to 58.7 kg/m², the findings indicate a uniform 22% complication rate across all categories, paving the way for more inclusive access to this life-changing procedure.
For professionals in plastic surgery and related fields, such research underscores the evolving standards in patient care. Canadian universities continue to lead in this domain, offering opportunities for researchers through positions listed on sites like higher-ed research jobs.
Photo by David Underland on Unsplash
Defining Masculinizing Chest Surgery
Masculinizing chest surgery, commonly referred to as top surgery or gender-affirming mastectomy, involves the removal of breast tissue to achieve a flatter, more masculine chest contour. It is primarily sought by transgender men (transmasculine individuals assigned female at birth who identify as male) and non-binary people experiencing gender dysphoria related to their chest.
The procedure typically follows these steps:
- Preoperative assessment: Psychological evaluation, hormone therapy review (if applicable), and medical clearance to ensure readiness.
- Surgical techniques: Options include peri-areolar (for smaller breasts), double incision with free nipple grafting (for larger breasts), or keyhole methods, chosen based on breast size, skin elasticity, and patient goals.
- Intraoperative process: General anesthesia, tissue excision, chest reshaping, nipple-areola complex repositioning or reconstruction.
- Postoperative recovery: Drains for 1-2 weeks, compression garments for 4-6 weeks, follow-up at 1 week, 1 month, 3 months, and up to one year.
This surgery significantly improves quality of life, reducing dysphoria and enhancing mental health, as evidenced by prior studies linking it to lower depression and anxiety rates.
In Canada, academic institutions like the University of Toronto, affiliated with leading hospitals, train surgeons in these techniques. Aspiring academics can find relevant professor jobs in health sciences programs.
Photo by Rebekah Vos on Unsplash
The Controversy Surrounding BMI in Surgical Candidacy
Body mass index has long been a gatekeeper for many surgeries due to perceived risks like wound healing issues, infections, and anesthesia complications. Categories include underweight/normal (<25 kg/m²), overweight (25-29.9), obese class I (30-34.9), class II (35-39.9), and class III (≥40, or morbid obesity).
In gender-affirming care, BMI cutoffs—often 30-40—have delayed or denied access, exacerbating inequities for transgender individuals who face higher obesity rates from factors like minority stress and hormone therapy. Canadian clinics vary: some like GrS Montréal assess case-by-case above normal BMI, while others cap at 38-40 post-anesthesia consult.
Prior U.S. studies showed mixed results, with some minor increases in seroma or dehiscence but no rise in serious events like hematoma. This new Canadian data strengthens the case against blanket BMI restrictions.
Researchers at the University of Toronto's Division of Plastic Surgery emphasize patient-centered approaches. For career advice in this field, check how to write a winning academic CV.
Photo by David Underland on Unsplash
Methodology of the Landmark Study
Led by Dr. Kathleen Armstrong, a University of Toronto plastic surgeon at Women's College Hospital, the retrospective chart review examined 530 patients aged 15-66 undergoing full mastectomies or reductions. Exclusions were minimal (two cases lacking follow-up or BMI data).
Complications were graded via Clavien-Dindo scale (I minor, up to IIIb requiring intervention). Analysis used Chi-squared tests and multivariable logistic regression adjusting for age and smoking. Ethics approved by Women's College Hospital REB #2024-0017; presented at the 78th Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons meeting.
Co-authors Neha Shah (BHSc), Emily MacLeod (RN), and Kyle Kirkham (MD) highlight rigorous perioperative protocols enabling ambulatory care for high-BMI patients.
Read the full study here.
Such collaborative research exemplifies higher education's role in healthcare innovation. Explore research assistant jobs in Canada.
Photo by Thomas Antonio on Unsplash
Key Results: No Significant Differences Across BMI Groups
Overall, 22% experienced complications, but rates were statistically similar across BMI and American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) classes (I healthy, II mild disease, III/IV severe).
| BMI Group | Patients (n) | Complication Rate (%) |
|---|---|---|
| <25 | ~200 (est.) | 22 |
| 25-29.9 | ~150 | 22 |
| 30-34.9 | ~100 | 22 |
| ≥35 | ~80 | 22 |
(Approximated from aggregate; no sig. diffs, p>0.05). Multivariate odds ratios showed no elevated risk for higher BMI vs. <25, nor ASA II/III-IV vs. I.
Highest BMI 58.7 kg/m² succeeded without excess issues, crediting protocols like enhanced monitoring.
These findings resonate in academic circles; Canadian university jobs in medicine are booming.
Photo by Alora Griffiths on Unsplash
Implications for Patients Seeking Top Surgery in Canada
This study advocates risk-stratified care over BMI bans, potentially reducing waitlists burdened by arbitrary cutoffs. In Canada, provincial coverage includes chest masculinization, but wait times stretch 8-16 months or more (e.g., McLean Clinic 8-10 months).
- Benefits: Broader access, fewer delays, improved mental health outcomes.
- Risks managed: Via protocols like prophylactic antibiotics, drains, smoking cessation.
- Stakeholder views: Trans advocates praise equity; surgeons note technical challenges in extreme BMI but affirm safety.
Learn more via Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons.
For healthcare career paths, visit higher ed jobs.
Photo by Benigno Hoyuela on Unsplash
Canadian Context: Access and Challenges in Gender-Affirming Care
Canada funds top surgery publicly across provinces, with 24 sites in seven provinces. Women's College Hospital, a U of T teaching site, exemplifies integrated care. Yet, high demand yields long waits; some travel to Seattle or Montreal.
BMI policies vary: Catalyst Surgical consults above 38; Dr. Bryan Chung unlikely above 40 at certain facilities. This study may influence guidelines, promoting ambulatory options.
University researchers drive policy; explore lecturer jobs in public health.
Photo by Rebekah Vos on Unsplash
Comparison with Global and Prior Research
Aligns with Johns Hopkins (2023): BMI not obstacle; high BMI no barrier to serious complications. Contrasts some U.S. data showing minor seroma increases, but confirms no hematoma/infection spike.
Largest Canadian cohort to date, ambulatory focus unique.
Internal: Postdoc success tips for similar studies.
Photo by Dimmis Vart on Unsplash
Perioperative Protocols for High-Risk Patients
Success attributes to:
- Preop optimization: Nutrition, cessation counseling.
- Intraop: Liposuction adjuncts, meticulous closure.
- Postop: Extended drains, telehealth follow-up.
Ambulatory feasible with these, reducing costs.
Trans Care BC resources.
Future Outlook and Research Directions
Prospective studies, patient-reported outcomes, long-term aesthetics needed. Policy shifts may follow, enhancing equity. U of T's role grows; university jobs in Toronto abundant.
Encourages rate my professor for top mentors.
Photo by Philip Oroni on Unsplash
Careers in Gender-Affirming Research and Surgery
This publication highlights opportunities in Canadian academia. From research assistants to faculty, roles abound. Check faculty jobs, postdoc positions, and career advice.
Post a job at recruitment.
